Sobin Christina, Kiley-Brabeck Karen, Monk Samantha Hadley, Khuri Jananne, Karayiorgou Maria
The Rockefeller University, New York, NY, United States.
Psychiatry Res. 2009 Mar 31;166(1):24-34. doi: 10.1016/j.psychres.2008.03.023. Epub 2009 Feb 14.
High rates of psychiatric impairment in adults with 22q11 deletion syndrome (22q11DS, also referred to as DiGeorge or velocardiofacial syndrome) suggest that behavioral trajectories of children with 22q11DS may provide critical etiologic insights. Past findings that report Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM) diagnoses are extremely variable; moreover, sex differences in behavior have not yet been examined. Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL) ratings from 82 children, including 51 with the 22q11DS and 31 control siblings, were analyzed. Strikingly consistent with rates of psychiatric impairment among affected adults, 25% of children with 22q11DS had high CBCL scores for Total Impairment, and 20% had high CBCL Internalizing Scale scores. Males accounted for 90% of high Internalizing scores and 67% of high Total Impairment scores. Attention and Social Problems were ubiquitous; more affected males than females (23% vs. 4%) scored high on Thought Problems. With regard to CBCL/DSM overlap, 20% of affected males as compared with 0 affected females had one or more high CBCL ratings in the absence of a DSM diagnosis. Behaviors of children with 22q11DS are characterized by marked sex differences when rated dimensionally, with significantly more males experiencing Internalizing and Thought Problems. Categorical diagnoses do not reflect behavioral differences between male and female children with 22q11DS, and may miss significant behavior problems in 20% of affected males.
患有22q11缺失综合征(22q11DS,也称为迪格奥尔格综合征或腭心面综合征)的成年人中精神障碍发生率较高,这表明患有22q11DS的儿童的行为轨迹可能提供关键的病因学见解。过去的研究结果表明,《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》(DSM)诊断极具变异性;此外,行为方面的性别差异尚未得到研究。对82名儿童的儿童行为量表(CBCL)评分进行了分析,其中包括51名患有22q11DS的儿童和31名对照同胞。与受影响成年人的精神障碍发生率惊人一致的是,25%的患有22q11DS的儿童CBCL总障碍评分较高,20%的儿童CBCL内化量表评分较高。在高内化评分中,男性占90%,在高总障碍评分中,男性占67%。注意力和社交问题普遍存在;在思维问题方面,受影响的男性得分高的比例高于女性(23%对4%)。关于CBCL/DSM的重叠情况,20%的受影响男性在没有DSM诊断的情况下有一项或多项CBCL高评分,而受影响女性为0。当进行维度评分时,患有22q11DS的儿童的行为具有明显的性别差异,有更多男性出现内化和思维问题。分类诊断并不能反映患有22q11DS的男童和女童之间的行为差异,并且可能会遗漏20%受影响男性中存在的重大行为问题。