Thelen E, Ulrich B D
Department of Psychology, Indiana University, Bloomington 47405.
Monogr Soc Res Child Dev. 1991;56(1):1-98; discussion 99-104.
When prelocomotor infants are supported on a motorized treadmill, they perform well-coordinated, alternating stepping movements that are kinematically similar to upright bipedal locomotion. This behavior appeared to be a component of independent walking that could not be recognized without the facilitating context of the treadmill. To understand the ontogenetic origins of treadmill stepping and its relation to later locomotion, we conducted a longitudinal study using an experimental strategy explicitly derived from dynamic systems theory. Dynamic systems theory postulates that new forms in behavior emerge from the cooperative interactions of multiple components within a task context. This approach focuses on the transitions, often nonlinear, where one preferred mode of behavior is replaced by a new form. Specific predictions about these transitions help uncover the processes by which development proceeds. Chapters II, III, and IV introduce dynamic principles of pattern formation and their application to development. In our application of these principles, we tested nine normal infants twice each month beginning from month 1 in a task where the treadmill speed was gradually scaled up and in an additional condition where each leg was driven by the treadmill at a different speed. Kinematic variables were derived from computerized movement analysis equipment and videotaped records. We also collected a number of anthropometric measurements, Bayley motor scores, and a behavioral mood scale for each month. Several infants stepped on the treadmill in their first month, but in all infants performance showed a rapidly rising slope from month 3 to month 6. Infants also showed corresponding improvement in adjustments to speed and relative coordination between the legs. In dynamic terminology, we found evidence that alternating stepping on the treadmill became an increasingly stable attractor during the middle months of the first year. Dynamic predictions that transitions would be characterized by increased variability and sensitivity to perturbation were borne out. Identifying the transitions enabled us to suggest a control parameter or variable moving the system into the stable response to the treadmill. This appeared to be the waning of flexor dominance in the legs during posture and movement that allowed the leg to be stretched back on the treadmill and so elicited the bilaterally alternating response. Further studies are needed to test this hypothesis. This dynamic analysis confirmed earlier suggestions that skill in general, and locomotion in particular, develops from the confluence of many participating elements and showed how emergent forms may result from changes in nonspecific components. A dynamic approach may be useful for understanding ontogenetic processes in other domains as well.
当运动前婴儿被支撑在电动跑步机上时,他们会做出协调良好的交替踏步动作,这些动作在运动学上与直立双足行走相似。这种行为似乎是独立行走的一个组成部分,如果没有跑步机的辅助环境,就无法被识别。为了理解跑步机踏步的个体发生起源及其与后期运动的关系,我们采用了一种明确源自动态系统理论的实验策略进行了一项纵向研究。动态系统理论假定,行为的新形式源自任务背景中多个组成部分的协同相互作用。这种方法关注的是行为的转变,通常是非线性的,即一种偏好的行为模式被一种新形式所取代。关于这些转变的具体预测有助于揭示发育过程。第二章、第三章和第四章介绍了模式形成的动态原理及其在发育中的应用。在我们对这些原理的应用中,我们从第1个月开始,每月对9名正常婴儿进行两次测试,一次是在跑步机速度逐渐增加的任务中,另一次是在每条腿由跑步机以不同速度驱动的附加条件下。运动学变量来自计算机化运动分析设备和录像记录。我们还每月收集一些人体测量数据、贝利运动评分和行为情绪量表。几个婴儿在第一个月就在跑步机上踏步了,但所有婴儿的表现从第3个月到第6个月都呈现出快速上升的趋势。婴儿在速度调整和双腿之间的相对协调性方面也有相应的改善。用动态术语来说,我们发现有证据表明,在第一年的中间几个月里,在跑步机上交替踏步成为了一个越来越稳定的吸引子。动态预测认为,转变将以变异性增加和对扰动的敏感性增加为特征,这一预测得到了证实。识别这些转变使我们能够提出一个控制参数或变量,它将系统带入对跑步机的稳定反应。这似乎是在姿势和运动过程中腿部屈肌优势的减弱,这使得腿部能够在跑步机上向后伸展,从而引发双侧交替反应。需要进一步的研究来验证这一假设。这种动态分析证实了早期的观点,即一般技能,特别是运动技能,是由许多参与要素的融合发展而来的,并展示了新兴形式可能是如何由非特定组成部分的变化产生的。动态方法可能也有助于理解其他领域的个体发生过程。