Fernandes Ritabelle, Hashimoto Susan, Masaki Kamal
Department of Geriatric Medicine, John A. Burns School of Medicine, University of Hawai'i, Honolulu, HI 96817, USA.
Hawaii Med J. 2008 Dec;67(12):317-21.
Internal medicine residents at the University of Hawai'i were surveyed in 2005 to identify their attitudes regarding ethics consultation based on exposure to ethics education as part of residency training. Our hypotheses were that senior residents are more likely than interns to request an ethics consultation; and providing or forgoing life-sustaining treatment would outrank other situations for requesting a consult. After two mailings, 46 out of 65 residents completed the survey (71% response rate). Statistical methods included Fisher's exact test for categorical variables, and general linear models to compare means between groups. A majority of residents stated that instruction on ethics was received through lectures and rounds. They were most likely to request an ethics consult for issues concerning medical futility and disagreement resolution. Comparing residents by yearof training for reason for ethics consultation, senior residents were more likely to request a consult for questions about artificial nutrition and hydration (p = 0.06). There was no difference between residents with or without previous exposure to ethics consultation or formal instruction in ethics and the likelihood of requesting a consultation in the future. A majority of residents felt it appropriate for any team member to request an ethics consultation. Ethics consultation can potentially be utilized to strengthen post-graduate medical education in keeping with the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education requirements.
2005年,夏威夷大学对内科住院医师进行了调查,以确定他们基于在住院医师培训中接受的伦理教育,对伦理咨询的态度。我们的假设是,高级住院医师比实习医师更有可能请求进行伦理咨询;并且在请求咨询的其他情况中,提供或放弃维持生命的治疗会排在前列。经过两次邮寄,65名住院医师中有46名完成了调查(回复率为71%)。统计方法包括对分类变量进行Fisher精确检验,以及用于比较组间均值的一般线性模型。大多数住院医师表示,他们通过讲座和查房接受了伦理方面的指导。他们最有可能就医疗无效和分歧解决等问题请求进行伦理咨询。按培训年份比较住院医师进行伦理咨询的原因,高级住院医师更有可能就人工营养和补液问题请求咨询(p = 0.06)。以前接受过或未接受过伦理咨询或伦理方面正式指导的住院医师,与未来请求咨询的可能性之间没有差异。大多数住院医师认为任何团队成员请求进行伦理咨询都是合适的。根据研究生医学教育认证委员会的要求,伦理咨询有可能被用于加强毕业后医学教育。