Larraín R E, Schaefer D M, Arp S C, Claus J R, Reed J D
Department of Animal Sciences, University of Wisconsin, Madison 53706, USA.
J Anim Sci. 2009 Jun;87(6):2089-95. doi: 10.2527/jas.2007-0433. Epub 2009 Feb 27.
The objective of this work was to compare feedlot performance, carcass characteristics, and beef sensory attributes from steers finished with diets based on corn, high-tannin sorghum (HTS), and a mix of both grains. Angus crossbred steers (n = 11 steers per treatment, initial BW = 404 +/- 18 kg) were finished on diets containing 765 g/kg of DM of corn, HTS, or a 1:1 mix of corn and HTS. Final BW (P < 0.01), ADG (P < 0.001), and G:F (P < 0.01) were reduced in steers fed HTS when compared with steers fed corn. Steers fed the mixed diet had greater G:F than the average between corn and HTS diets (P = 0.04), which indicated that mixing corn and HTS had positive associative effects. Estimated NE(m) of HTS was 1.91, and estimated NE(g) was 1.35 Mcal/kg of DM. Hot carcass weight (P < 0.01), trimmed carcass weight (P < 0.01), yield grade (P = 0.04), and 12th-rib fat thickness (P = 0.01) were less in steers fed HTS than in those fed corn. Estimated percentage of HCW as boneless, closely trimmed retail cuts was greater in steers fed HTS compared with those fed corn (P = 0.02) but, due to the decreased HCW, estimated amount of boneless, closely trimmed retail cuts was less in steers fed HTS than in those fed corn (P = 0.03). Steers fed HTS had greater pH on LM (P = 0.02) than steers fed corn, but the difference was small (5.42 +/- 0.02 vs. 5.36 +/- 0.02, respectively) and within the range of normal beef pH. Diet had no effect on Warner-Bratzler shear values (P > or = 0.72). Multivariate ANOVA indicated a difference in sensory attributes of beef from corn and HTS steers (Wilks' Lambda, P = 0.04). When evaluating each sensory attribute independently, panelists found beef from steers fed HTS to be less juicy (P < 0.01), less tender (P = 0.03), and more cooked (P < 0.01) than beef from animals fed corn. Data from this study indicated that by using a 1:1 mix of HTS and corn it is possible to finish steers to similar BW and carcass quality as by using a corn-based diet. Also, total replacement of corn by HTS in the diets produced lighter and leaner animals. Total replacement of corn by HTS in the finishing diet changed beef sensory attributes, reducing the perception of beef tenderness and juiciness by panelists but without changing instrumental tenderness.
本研究的目的是比较以玉米、高单宁高粱(HTS)以及两者混合谷物为基础日粮育肥的阉牛的育肥性能、胴体特性和牛肉感官属性。安格斯杂交阉牛(每组n = 11头阉牛,初始体重 = 404±18千克)分别用含765克/千克干物质的玉米、HTS或1:1玉米与HTS混合日粮进行育肥。与饲喂玉米的阉牛相比,饲喂HTS的阉牛最终体重(P < 0.01)、平均日增重(ADG,P < 0.001)和料重比(G:F,P < 0.01)均降低。饲喂混合日粮的阉牛的G:F高于玉米和HTS日粮的平均值(P = 0.04),这表明玉米和HTS混合具有正协同效应。HTS的估计净能(NE(m))为1.91,估计净能(NE(g))为1.35兆卡/千克干物质。与饲喂玉米的阉牛相比,饲喂HTS的阉牛热胴体重(P < 0.01)、修整后胴体重(P < 0.01)、产量等级(P = 0.04)和第12肋骨处脂肪厚度(P = 0.01)均较低。与饲喂玉米的阉牛相比,饲喂HTS的阉牛的胴体净肉率(估计为去骨、精细修整零售切块的百分比)更高(P = 0.02),但由于热胴体重降低,饲喂HTS的阉牛的去骨、精细修整零售切块估计量低于饲喂玉米的阉牛(P = 0.03)。与饲喂玉米的阉牛相比,饲喂HTS的阉牛腰大肌的pH值更高(P = 0.02),但差异较小(分别为5.42±(0.02)和5.36±(0.02)),且在正常牛肉pH值范围内。日粮对沃纳-布拉茨勒剪切值无影响(P≥0.72)。多变量方差分析表明,来自玉米育肥阉牛和HTS育肥阉牛的牛肉感官属性存在差异(威尔克斯λ,P = 0.04)。当独立评估每个感官属性时,评判员发现,与饲喂玉米的阉牛的牛肉相比,饲喂HTS的阉牛的牛肉多汁性较差(P < 0.01)、嫩度较差(P = 0.03)且熟度更高(P < 0.01)。本研究数据表明,使用1:1的HTS和玉米混合物育肥阉牛,可使其达到与使用玉米日粮育肥相似的体重和胴体品质。此外,日粮中用HTS完全替代玉米可使阉牛体重更轻、胴体更瘦。育肥日粮中用HTS完全替代玉米会改变牛肉的感官属性,降低评判员对牛肉嫩度和多汁性的感知,但不会改变仪器测定的嫩度。