Tobler Kyle J, Wilson Philip K, Napolitano Peter G
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Madigan Army Medical Center, Tacoma, Washington 98431, USA.
J Cancer Educ. 2009;24(1):36-9. doi: 10.1080/08858190802664354.
The objective of this study was to compare the frequency of articles in women's magazines that address breast cancer, lung cancer, and tobacco use from 1987-2003 and to ascertain whether the annual number of articles reflected corresponding cancer mortality rates from breast cancer and lung cancer and the number of female smokers throughout this time period.
We reviewed 13 women's magazines published in the United States from 1987-2003 using the search terms breast cancer, lung cancer, smoking, and tobacco. We reviewed the abstracts or entire articles to determine relevance.
A total of 1044 articles addressed breast cancer, lung cancer, or tobacco use: 681 articles related to breast cancer, 47 related to lung cancer, and 316 related to tobacco use. The greater number of breast cancer articles compared to lung cancer articles was statistically significant (P value < .0001). The greater number of breast cancer articles compared to lung cancer articles combined with tobacco use articles was also statistically significant (P = .0012). The annual number breast cancer articles compared to the breast cancer mortality rate demonstrated a negative relationship. The annual number of lung cancer articles compared to the lung cancer mortality rate demonstrated no relationship. The annual number of tobacco use articles compared to the annual number of female smokers demonstrated no relationship.
Breast cancer was more frequently represented than lung cancer or tobacco use in women's magazines from 1987-2003 despite the increase in lung cancer mortality, a decrease in breast cancer mortality, and an insignificant change in the number of female smokers.
本研究的目的是比较1987年至2003年女性杂志中涉及乳腺癌、肺癌和烟草使用的文章频率,并确定文章的年度数量是否反映了这段时间内乳腺癌和肺癌相应的癌症死亡率以及女性吸烟者的数量。
我们使用搜索词乳腺癌、肺癌、吸烟和烟草,对1987年至2003年在美国出版的13本女性杂志进行了回顾。我们审查了摘要或整篇文章以确定相关性。
共有1044篇文章涉及乳腺癌、肺癌或烟草使用:681篇与乳腺癌相关,47篇与肺癌相关,316篇与烟草使用相关。与肺癌文章相比,乳腺癌文章数量更多具有统计学意义(P值<0.0001)。与肺癌文章和烟草使用文章的总和相比,乳腺癌文章数量更多也具有统计学意义(P = 0.0012)。与乳腺癌死亡率相比,乳腺癌文章的年度数量呈现负相关。与肺癌死亡率相比,肺癌文章的年度数量没有相关性。与女性吸烟者的年度数量相比,烟草使用文章的年度数量没有相关性。
尽管肺癌死亡率上升、乳腺癌死亡率下降且女性吸烟者数量变化不显著,但在1987年至2003年的女性杂志中,乳腺癌的报道频率高于肺癌或烟草使用。