Holland C A, Hill R, Cooke R
Psychology, School of Life.ealth Sciences, Aston University, Birmingham B4 7ET, UK.
Health Educ Res. 2009 Aug;24(4):674-85. doi: 10.1093/her/cyp003. Epub 2009 Mar 5.
Self-identity as a careful pedestrian has not been fully considered in previous work on predicting intention to cross the road, or actual crossing behaviour, in non-optimal situations. Evidence suggests that self-identity may be a better predictor than attitudes in situations where decision-making styles have become habitual ways to respond. This study compared contributions of self-identity and attitudes to the prediction of intentions in two situations differing in level of habitual crossing expectation, and to crossing behaviour. Three hundred and sixty-two adults (17-92 years) completed a questionnaire measuring self-identity, attitudes, intentions, experience, social identity variables (e.g. age, gender) and personal limitations (mobility). Two hundred and five participants also completed a road-crossing simulation. Self-identity and attitude were both shown as significant independent predictors of intention in both situations. However, self-identity was less effective as a predictor in the higher risk scenario, where intention to perform the behaviour was lower, and for participants aged >75 years who had lower intention across scenarios. Self-identity strongly predicted intention to cross, which in turn predicted behaviour, but self-identity did not directly predict behaviour. Self-identity was strongly predicted by age. Implications for theories of compensation in older age and for design and targeting of pedestrian safety education are discussed.
在以往关于预测非最佳情况下过马路意图或实际过马路行为的研究中,尚未充分考虑将自己视为谨慎行人的自我认同。有证据表明,在决策方式已成为习惯性反应方式的情况下,自我认同可能比态度更能预测行为。本研究比较了自我认同和态度在两种习惯性过马路预期水平不同的情况下对意图预测以及对过马路行为的影响。362名成年人(17 - 92岁)完成了一份问卷,测量自我认同、态度、意图、经验、社会认同变量(如年龄、性别)和个人限制(行动能力)。205名参与者还完成了一次过马路模拟。在两种情况下,自我认同和态度均被证明是意图的显著独立预测因素。然而,在风险较高的场景中,即执行该行为的意图较低的情况下,以及在所有场景中意图都较低的75岁以上参与者中,自我认同作为预测因素的效果较差。自我认同强烈预测过马路意图,而意图又反过来预测行为,但自我认同并不能直接预测行为。年龄对自我认同有强烈影响。本文讨论了其对老年人补偿理论以及行人安全教育设计和目标定位的启示。