Podiatry Services, Sheffield PCT, Jordanthorpe Health Centre, Sheffield, S8 8DJ, UK.
J Foot Ankle Res. 2009 Mar 13;2:7. doi: 10.1186/1757-1146-2-7.
Core podiatry involves treatment of the nails, corns and callus and also giving footwear and foot health advice. Though it is an integral part of current podiatric practice little evidence is available to support its efficacy in terms of research and audit data. This information is important in order to support the current NHS commissioning process where services are expected to provide data on standards including outcomes. This study aimed to increase the evidence base for this area of practice by conducting a multi-centre audit in 8 NHS podiatry departments over a 1-year period.
The outcome measure used in this audit was the Podiatry Health Questionnaire which is a self completed short measure of foot health including a pain visual analogue scale and a section for the podiatrist to rate an individual's foot health based on their podiatric problems. The patient questionnaire was completed by individuals prior to receiving podiatry care and then 2 weeks after treatment to assess the effect of core podiatry in terms of pain and foot health.
1047 patients completed both questionnaires, with an age range from 26-95 years and a mean age of 72.9 years. The podiatrists clinical rating at baseline showed 75% of patients had either slight or moderate podiatric problems. The differences in questionnaire and visual analogue scores before and after treatment were determined according to three categories - better, same, worse and 75% of patients' scores either remained the same or improved after core podiatry treatment. A student t-test showed a statistical significant difference in pre and post treatment scores where P < 0.001, though the confidence interval indicated that the improvement was relatively small.
Core podiatry has been shown to sustain or improve foot health and pain in 75% of the patients taking part in the audit. Simple outcome measures including pain scales should be used routinely in podiatric practice to assess the affect of different aspects of treatments and improve the evidence base for podiatry.
核心足病治疗包括指甲、鸡眼和胼胝的处理,以及提供鞋类和足部健康建议。尽管这是当前足病实践的一个组成部分,但在研究和审计数据方面,几乎没有证据支持其疗效。为了支持当前的国民保健制度委托程序,需要了解这方面的信息,该程序要求服务部门提供包括结果在内的标准数据。这项研究旨在通过在 8 个 NHS 足病科进行为期 1 年的多中心审计,为这一实践领域增加证据基础。
本审计使用的结果测量是足病健康问卷,这是一种自我完成的足部健康简短测量方法,包括疼痛视觉模拟量表和足病医生根据他们的足病问题对个人足部健康进行评分的部分。患者问卷在接受足病治疗前由个人填写,然后在治疗后 2 周再次填写,以评估核心足病在疼痛和足部健康方面的效果。
1047 名患者完成了两份问卷,年龄范围为 26-95 岁,平均年龄为 72.9 岁。基线时足病医生的临床评分显示,75%的患者有轻度或中度的足病问题。根据三个类别(更好、相同、更差)确定治疗前后问卷和视觉模拟评分的差异:75%的患者的评分要么保持不变,要么在接受核心足病治疗后有所改善。学生 t 检验显示治疗前后评分有统计学显著差异,P < 0.001,尽管置信区间表明改善相对较小。
在参与审计的患者中,75%的患者接受核心足病治疗后,足部健康和疼痛得到维持或改善。应在足病实践中常规使用包括疼痛量表在内的简单结果测量方法,以评估不同治疗方面的影响,并为足病学提供更好的证据基础。