Nomhwange Terna I, Whitty Christopher J M
Clinical Research Unit, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, Keppel Street, London WC1E 7HT, UK.
Trop Doct. 2009 Apr;39(2):90-2. doi: 10.1258/td.2008.080200.
Over-diagnosis of malaria has previously been described, especially in East Africa. Abuja is the capital of the most populous country in Africa. Over-prescription of artemisinin-based combination therapy (ACT) antimalarials in Nigeria on the scale reported from other countries will result in substantial unnecessary use of this class of drug. In a study of 1000 children seen in the outpatient paediatric clinics of four district hospitals in Abuja, 669 had history of fever, of whom 616 (92%) were diagnosed with malaria. Only 24 (3.8%) where confirmed by positive malaria slides. Of 82 malaria tests requested, 32 (40%) were not available when clinicians wrote their prescriptions. Of 256 children prescribed an ACT, 11 (4.4%) were test negative, eight (3.1%) test positive, in 11 (4.3%) the test was not available and the test was not requested for 219 (86%). The proportion of available negative slides for patients treated with an antimalarial was 23/26 (88%), which was similar to the 22/24 (91%) treated with an antimalarial who were test positive. Testing for malaria made almost no impact on ACT prescription or on all other antimalarials and antibiotics. Based on these findings there is high possibility of massive over prescription of antimalarials.
此前已有关于疟疾过度诊断的描述,尤其是在东非。阿布贾是非洲人口最多的国家的首都。在尼日利亚,按其他国家报告的规模过度开具以青蒿素为基础的联合疗法(ACT)抗疟药,将导致这类药物的大量不必要使用。在一项对阿布贾四家地区医院儿科门诊所见的1000名儿童的研究中,669名有发热史,其中616名(92%)被诊断为疟疾。经疟原虫玻片阳性确诊的仅24名(3.8%)。在开具处方时,所申请的82次疟疾检测中有32次(40%)结果未出。在开具ACT的256名儿童中,11名(4.4%)检测为阴性,8名(3.1%)检测为阳性,11名(4.3%)检测结果未出,219名(86%)未申请检测。接受抗疟药治疗的患者中可获得的阴性玻片比例为23/26(88%),这与接受抗疟药治疗且检测为阳性的22/24(91%)相似。疟疾检测对ACT处方以及所有其他抗疟药和抗生素的处方几乎没有影响。基于这些发现,抗疟药存在大量过度处方的可能性很大。