Macinko James, Starfield Barbara, Erinosho Temitope
Department of Nutrition, Food Studies, and Public Health, New York University, New York, USA.
J Ambul Care Manage. 2009 Apr-Jun;32(2):150-71. doi: 10.1097/JAC.0b013e3181994221.
This article assesses 36 peer-reviewed studies of the impact of primary healthcare (PHC) on health outcomes in low- and middle-income countries. Studies were abstracted and assessed according to where they took place, the research design used, target population, primary care measures, and overall conclusions. Results indicate that the bulk of evidence for PHC effectiveness is focused on infant and child health, but there is also evidence of the positive role PHC has on population health over time. Although the peer-reviewed literature is lacking in rigorous experimental studies, a small number of relatively well-designed observational studies and the consistency of findings generally support the contention that an integrated approach to primary care can improve health. A few large-scale experiences also help identify elements of good practice. The review concludes with several recommendations for future studies, including a focus on better conceptualizing and measuring PHC, further investigation into the advantages of comprehensive over selective PHC, need for experimental or quasi-experimental research designs that allow testing of the independent effect of primary care on outcomes over time, and a more detailed conceptual framework guiding overall evaluation design that places limits on the parameters under consideration and describes relationships among different levels and types of data likely to be collected in the evaluation process.
本文评估了36项关于初级卫生保健(PHC)对低收入和中等收入国家健康结果影响的同行评审研究。根据研究开展的地点、所采用的研究设计、目标人群、初级保健措施以及总体结论对研究进行了摘要提取和评估。结果表明,初级卫生保健有效性的大部分证据集中在婴幼儿健康方面,但也有证据表明,随着时间推移,初级卫生保健对人群健康具有积极作用。尽管同行评审文献中缺乏严格的实验研究,但一些设计相对良好的观察性研究以及研究结果的一致性总体上支持了这样一种观点,即综合初级保健方法可以改善健康状况。一些大规模的实践经验也有助于确定良好做法的要素。该综述最后对未来研究提出了若干建议,包括着重更好地对初级卫生保健进行概念化和衡量,进一步研究全面初级卫生保健相对于选择性初级卫生保健的优势,需要采用实验性或准实验性研究设计,以便能够检验初级保健随时间推移对结果的独立影响,以及需要一个更详细的概念框架来指导总体评估设计,该框架对所考虑的参数加以限制,并描述在评估过程中可能收集的不同层次和类型数据之间的关系。