Dipaola Christian P, Bible Jesse E, Biswas Debdut, Dipaola Matthew, Grauer Jonathan N, Rechtine Glenn R
Department of Orthopaedics and Rehabilitation, University of Rochester, NY, USA.
Spine J. 2009 Jul;9(7):537-44. doi: 10.1016/j.spinee.2009.02.005. Epub 2009 Mar 28.
Osteoporosis and osteomalacia are significant risk factors for fracture and spine instrumentation failure. Low-energy fractures are becoming increasingly more common because of an increase in life expectancy and age of the population. Decreased bone density is an independent risk factor for instrumentation failure in spinal fusion operations.
To assess the awareness and practice patterns of spine surgeons regarding metabolic bone disorders and osteoporosis with emphasis on fracture care and arthrodesis.
STUDY DESIGN/SETTING: Questionnaire study.
Spine surgeons attending the "Disorders of the Spine" conference (January 2007, Whistler, British Columbia, Canada).
Respondent reported frequencies of diagnostics, screening, and treatment methods for patients with low-energy spine fractures, pseudoarthrosis, and those undergoing spinal arthrodesis.
A ten-question survey was administered to orthopedic surgeons and neurosurgeons who treated spine fractures and degenerative spine conditions in their practice. The survey was given to those who were attending a continuing medical education spinal disorders conference. The survey asked about treatment patterns with respect to osteoporosis and osteomalacia workup and treatment for patients with low-energy spine fractures, pseudoarthrosis, and those undergoing spinal arthrodesis.
Of the 133 surgeons to whom the questionnaire was distributed at this meeting, 114 questionnaires were returned that corresponds to a response rate of 86%. Twenty-one surveys were excluded because of incomplete biographical information, resulting in a total of 93 completed questionnaires that were available for analysis. When treating patients with low-energy spine fractures, 60% checked dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) and 39% checked metabolic laboratories (of those who did not order laboratories and DEXA about 63% refer for treatment). Before instrumented fusion, 44% of those queried checked DEXA and 12% checked metabolic laboratories (vitamin D, parathyroid hormone [PTH], and calcium [Ca]). Before noninstrumented fusion, 22% checked DEXA and 11% checked metabolic laboratories. Before addressing pseudoarthrosis, 19% checked DEXA and 20% checked metabolic laboratories.
Despite of the large number of elderly patients undergoing spine care and the high incidence of osteoporosis and/or osteomalacia in this population, a large portion of the spine surgeons who responded to the survey reported that they do not perform routine osteoporosis/osteomalacia workups. Of those who do perform workups, some commented that it will change their surgical plan or preoperative treatment. It appears that there is a need for increased awareness among spine specialists regarding osteoporosis screening and treatment. Osteoporosis practice patterns may also be affected with newly evolving government quality reporting regulations.
骨质疏松症和骨软化症是骨折和脊柱内固定失败的重要危险因素。由于预期寿命延长和人口老龄化,低能量骨折越来越普遍。骨密度降低是脊柱融合手术中内固定失败的独立危险因素。
评估脊柱外科医生对代谢性骨病和骨质疏松症的认知及实践模式,重点关注骨折护理和关节融合术。
研究设计/地点:问卷调查研究。
参加“脊柱疾病”会议(2007年1月,加拿大不列颠哥伦比亚省惠斯勒)的脊柱外科医生。
受访者报告的低能量脊柱骨折、假关节患者以及接受脊柱关节融合术患者的诊断、筛查和治疗方法的频率。
对在实践中治疗脊柱骨折和退行性脊柱疾病的骨科医生和神经外科医生进行了一项包含10个问题的调查。该调查针对参加继续医学教育脊柱疾病会议的人员。调查询问了关于骨质疏松症和骨软化症检查以及低能量脊柱骨折、假关节患者和接受脊柱关节融合术患者治疗的模式。
在本次会议上分发问卷的133名外科医生中,回收了114份问卷,回复率为86%。由于传记信息不完整,排除了21份调查问卷,最终共有93份完整问卷可供分析。在治疗低能量脊柱骨折患者时,60%的医生进行了双能X线吸收法(DEXA)检查,39%的医生进行了代谢实验室检查(在未进行实验室检查和DEXA检查的医生中,约63%会转诊治疗)。在进行器械融合术前,44%的被调查者进行了DEXA检查,12%的人进行了代谢实验室检查(维生素D、甲状旁腺激素[PTH]和钙[Ca])。在进行非器械融合术前,22%的人进行了DEXA检查,11%的人进行了代谢实验室检查。在处理假关节之前,19%的人进行了DEXA检查,2%的人进行了代谢实验室检查。
尽管有大量老年患者接受脊柱治疗,且该人群中骨质疏松症和/或骨软化症的发病率较高,但对调查做出回应的大部分脊柱外科医生报告称他们不进行常规的骨质疏松症/骨软化症检查。在进行检查的医生中,一些人表示这会改变他们的手术计划或术前治疗。脊柱专科医生对骨质疏松症筛查和治疗的认识似乎需要提高。骨质疏松症的实践模式也可能会受到新出台的政府质量报告规定的影响。