Stebbing A R D
Plymouth Marine Laboratory, Plymouth, Devon, United Kingdom.
Nonlinearity Biol Toxicol Med. 2003 Oct;1(4):493-511. doi: 10.1080/15401420390271100.
To date there is no single shared property of the various physical and chemical agents that elicit the beta-curve to account for its form, leading to the proposition that hormesis is a consequence of the nonspecificity of adaptive responses. It is argued that adaptive responses to toxic agents may be expected to follow the beta-curve. Four kinds of examples are reviewed (enzyme activity, sequestration and repair, and reproductive and homeostatic responses) that corroborate this proposition. The homeostasis example (incorporating homeorhesis) is considered in more detail, using the author's published hydroid experimental growth data, to show that both the alpha- and beta-curves are satisfactorily explained in this way. Many consider that hormesis is merely due to regulatory overcorrections, but it is proposed that it is a consequence of adaptations of the rate-sensitive growth control mechanism (homeorhesis) to sustained levels of inhibition to which the growth control mechanism adapts. In response to low levels of inhibition, upward adjustment of preferred growth rates confers greater resistance to inhibition, with growth hormesis as a cumulative byproduct.
迄今为止,引发β曲线的各种物理和化学因子并没有单一的共同特性来解释其形式,这导致了一种观点,即兴奋效应是适应性反应非特异性的结果。有人认为,对有毒物质的适应性反应可能会遵循β曲线。文中回顾了四类例子(酶活性、螯合与修复、生殖和体内平衡反应)来证实这一观点。利用作者已发表的水螅实验生长数据,对体内平衡的例子(包括稳衡性)进行了更详细的探讨,以表明α曲线和β曲线都能以这种方式得到令人满意的解释。许多人认为兴奋效应仅仅是由于调节过度矫正,但有人提出,它是速率敏感生长控制机制(稳衡性)适应持续抑制水平的结果,生长控制机制会适应这种抑制。针对低水平的抑制,偏好生长速率的向上调整赋予了对抑制更强的抵抗力,生长兴奋效应则是一种累积的副产物。