Guehring Thorsten, Wilde Geoff, Sumner Matthew, Grünhagen Thijs, Karney Graeme B, Tirlapur Uday K, Urban Jill P G
University of Oxford, Oxford, UK.
Arthritis Rheum. 2009 Apr;60(4):1026-34. doi: 10.1002/art.24407.
The nucleus pulposus (NP) of the intervertebral disc develops from the notochord. Humans and other species in which notochordal cells (NCs) disappear to be replaced by chondrocyte-like mature NP cells (MNPCs) frequently develop disc degeneration, unlike other species that retain NCs. The reasons for NC disappearance are unknown. In humans, the change in cell phenotype (to MNPCs) coincides with changes that decrease nutrient supply to the avascular disc. We undertook this study to test the hypothesis that the consequent nutrient stress could be associated with NC disappearance.
We measured cell densities and metabolic rates in 3-dimensional cultures of porcine NCs and bovine MNPCs, and we determined survival rates under conditions of nutrient deprivation. We used scanning electron microscopy to examine end plate porosity of discs with NCs and those with MNPCs. Nutrient-metabolite profiles and cell viability were calculated as a function of cell density and disc size in a consumption/diffusion mathematical model.
NCs were more active metabolically and more susceptible to nutrient deprivation than were MNPCs. Hypoxia increased rates of glycolysis in NCs but not in MNPCs. Higher end plate porosity in discs with NCs suggested greater nutrient supply in keeping with higher nutritional demands. Mathematical simulations and experiments using an analog disc diffusion chamber indicated that a fall in nutrient concentrations resulting from increased diffusion distance during growth and/or a fall in blood supply through end plate changes could instigate NC disappearance.
NCs demand more energy and are less resistant to nutritional stress than MNPCs, which may shed light on the fate of NCs in humans. This provides important information about prospective NC tissue engineering approaches.
椎间盘的髓核由脊索发育而来。与保留脊索细胞(NCs)的其他物种不同,人类和其他脊索细胞消失并被软骨样成熟髓核细胞(MNPCs)取代的物种经常发生椎间盘退变。NCs消失的原因尚不清楚。在人类中,细胞表型向MNPCs的转变与减少对无血管椎间盘营养供应的变化同时发生。我们进行这项研究以检验以下假设:随之而来的营养应激可能与NCs消失有关。
我们测量了猪NCs和牛MNPCs三维培养物中的细胞密度和代谢率,并确定了营养剥夺条件下的存活率。我们使用扫描电子显微镜检查有NCs和有MNPCs的椎间盘终板孔隙率。在一个消耗/扩散数学模型中,根据细胞密度和椎间盘大小计算营养代谢物谱和细胞活力。
与MNPCs相比,NCs代谢更活跃,对营养剥夺更敏感。缺氧增加了NCs中的糖酵解速率,但在MNPCs中没有。有NCs的椎间盘终板孔隙率较高,表明营养供应增加,与更高的营养需求一致。使用模拟椎间盘扩散室的数学模拟和实验表明,生长过程中扩散距离增加导致的营养浓度下降和/或通过终板变化导致的血液供应下降可能促使NCs消失。
与MNPCs相比,NCs需要更多能量,对营养应激的抵抗力更低,这可能有助于揭示人类NCs的命运。这为前瞻性的NC组织工程方法提供了重要信息。