Constantinescu Florina, Goucher Suzanne, Weinstein Arthur, Smith Wally, Fraenkel Liana
Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, VA, USA.
Arthritis Rheum. 2009 Apr 15;61(4):413-8. doi: 10.1002/art.24338.
Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patient preferences may account for some of the variability in treatment between racial groups. How and why treatment preferences differ by race is not well understood. We sought to determine whether African American and white RA patients differ in how they evaluate the specific risks and benefits related to medications.
A total of 136 RA patients completed a conjoint analysis interactive computer survey to determine how they valued the specific risks and benefits related to treatment characteristics. The importance that respondents assigned to each characteristic and the ratio of the importance that patients attached to overall benefit versus overall risk were calculated. Subjects having a risk ratio <1 were classified as being risk averse.
The mean age of the study sample was 55 years (range 22-84). Forty-nine percent were African American and 51% were white. African American subjects assigned the greatest importance to the theoretical risk of cancer, whereas white subjects were most concerned with the likelihood of remission and halting radiographic progression. Fifty-two percent of African American subjects were found to be risk averse compared with 12% of the white subjects (P < 0.0001). Race remained strongly associated with risk aversion (adjusted odds ratio [95% confidence interval] 8.4 [3.1, -23.1]) after adjusting for relevant covariates.
African American patients attach greater importance to the risks of toxicity and less importance to the likelihood of benefit than their white counterparts. Effective risk communication and improved understanding of expected benefits may help decrease unwanted variability in health care.
类风湿关节炎(RA)患者的偏好可能是种族群体间治疗差异的部分原因。治疗偏好在种族间如何以及为何不同尚不清楚。我们试图确定非裔美国人和白人RA患者在评估药物相关特定风险和益处方面是否存在差异。
共有136名RA患者完成了一项联合分析交互式计算机调查,以确定他们如何评估与治疗特征相关的特定风险和益处。计算了受访者赋予每个特征的重要性以及患者赋予总体益处与总体风险的重要性之比。风险比<1的受试者被归类为风险厌恶型。
研究样本的平均年龄为55岁(范围22 - 84岁)。49%为非裔美国人,51%为白人。非裔美国受试者认为癌症的理论风险最为重要,而白人受试者最关注缓解及阻止影像学进展的可能性。发现52%的非裔美国受试者为风险厌恶型,而白人受试者中这一比例为12%(P < 0.0001)。在调整相关协变量后,种族与风险厌恶仍密切相关(调整后的优势比[95%置信区间]为8.4 [3.1, -23.1])。
与白人患者相比,非裔美国患者更重视毒性风险,而对获益可能性的重视程度较低。有效的风险沟通以及对预期益处的更好理解可能有助于减少医疗保健中不必要的差异。