Martínez Ramos D, Daroca José J M, Escrig Sos J, Paiva Coronel G, Alcalde Sánchez M, Salvador Sanchís J L
Service of Digestive and General Surgery, Hospital General de Castellón, Spain.
Rev Esp Enferm Dig. 2009 Feb;101(2):117-20, 121-4. doi: 10.4321/s1130-01082009000200005.
Controversy remains about the management of gallstone ileus. While some authors propose enterotomy, others defend the one-stage procedure (simultaneously fistula repair). The objective of the present study was to analyze management options and comparative study their results.
Retrospective and descriptive study with revision of clinical stories of patients with the diagnosis of gallstone ileus between 1987 and 2008. All the following variables were recorded: dates of hospital admission, surgery and discharge, age, sex, pathological antecedents, preoperative or intraoperative diagnosis, treatment, location of the fistula and location of the obstruction. End-result variables were: postoperative complications, mortality, complications during the follow-up and biliary complications.
A total of 40 patients were included of 46,648 admissions. Age, comorbidity, and intraoperative diagnosis were related with poorer short- and long-outcomes. The percentage of postoperative complications was similar for groups with and without fistula repair. Mortality was higher in the group with fistula repair (15 vs. 25%). Biliary complications were more frequent in the group without fistula repair (11 vs. 0%). Sex, location of the fistula and location of the obstruction did not be related with the prognosis.
One-stage procedure is related with higher mortality rate than enterotomy alone. Nevertheless, fistula repair reduces the number of biliary complications during the follow-up.
关于胆石性肠梗阻的治疗仍存在争议。一些作者建议进行肠切开术,另一些人则支持一期手术(同时进行瘘管修复)。本研究的目的是分析治疗方案并比较其结果。
回顾性描述性研究,回顾了1987年至2008年间诊断为胆石性肠梗阻患者的临床病历。记录了以下所有变量:入院日期、手术日期和出院日期、年龄、性别、病理病史、术前或术中诊断、治疗方法、瘘管位置和梗阻位置。最终结果变量包括:术后并发症、死亡率、随访期间的并发症和胆道并发症。
在46648例入院患者中,共纳入40例患者。年龄、合并症和术中诊断与短期和长期预后较差有关。有瘘管修复组和无瘘管修复组的术后并发症发生率相似。瘘管修复组的死亡率较高(15%对25%)。无瘘管修复组的胆道并发症更常见(11%对0%)。性别、瘘管位置和梗阻位置与预后无关。
一期手术的死亡率高于单纯肠切开术。然而,瘘管修复可减少随访期间的胆道并发症数量。