[美学隆乳术中的先天性不对称:发生率、术后满意度及手术选择]
[Constitutional asymmetries in aesthetic breast augmentation: incidence, postoperative satisfaction and surgical options].
作者信息
Médard de Chardon V, Balaguer T, Chignon-Sicard B, Ihrai T, Lebreton E
机构信息
Service de chirurgie plastique, réparatrice et esthétique, hôpital St-Roch, 5, rue Pierre-Dévoluy, 06000 Nice, France.
出版信息
Ann Chir Plast Esthet. 2009 Aug;54(4):340-7. doi: 10.1016/j.anplas.2009.01.034. Epub 2009 Apr 1.
INTRODUCTION
The clinically observable, constitutional breast asymmetries are frequent and physiological in the general population. Although there has been a preponderance of literature concerning breast augmentation, a conspicuous lack of data exists regarding the preoperative breast and chest wall asymmetries seen in the patient seeking consultation for aesthetic breast augmentation. These asymmetries can lead to postoperative dissatisfaction in patients.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
An independent plastic surgeon analysed the data of 200 patients who had a primary aesthetic breast augmentation. The mean follow-up was 36 months. All patients had pre- and postoperative standardized pictures of the anterior chest wall. The clinical examination was achieved using an original evaluation form. Patients were also asked to fill an exhaustive satisfaction form. Breasts and chest wall asymmetries were diagnosed by clinical examination and photographic analysis. Mastopexy-augmentations, breast reconstructions, breast malformations (tuberous breasts and Poland syndrome) and patients with incomplete data were excluded from the study. Stastical analysis was done using SPSS software version 15.
RESULTS
There were 77% of chest wall and breast asymmetries and 69,5% of breasts asymmetries (26,5% of breast mound volume asymmetry and 62,5% of shape asymmetry). An isolated chest wall asymmetry was found in 17% of patients. Scoliosis was the main cause of asymmetry (52,9% of chest wall asymmetries) as it is often associated with chest wall rotation, chest wall depression, submammary depression or rib asymmetry. Patients often noticed an asymmetry postoperatively (28%). Among the patients complaining from a postoperative asymmetry, 83,3% had a constitutional breast or chest wall asymmetry. Asymmetry was the third cause of dissatisfaction and the third argument for revision surgery (after volume dissatisfaction and ptosis). Thirty per cent of patients asking for a surgical revision and 35.3% of unsatisfied patients complained about asymmetry, which was preoperative in 83.3% of cases.
CONCLUSION
The asymmetry rate of our study is compared with the others studies found in the literature. In the daily practice, asymmetry can be diagnosed by a complete clinical examination and standardized chest wall pictures. Patients with constitutional asymmetry should be educated, helping to increase postoperative satisfaction. The authors propose and discuss a surgical pattern for the handling of the different types of asymmetries in breast augmentation.
引言
临床上可观察到的乳房先天性不对称在普通人群中很常见且属于生理性现象。尽管已有大量关于隆乳术的文献,但对于寻求美容隆乳咨询的患者术前乳房及胸壁不对称情况,明显缺乏相关数据。这些不对称可能导致患者术后不满意。
材料与方法
一位独立的整形外科医生分析了200例行一期美容隆乳术患者的数据。平均随访时间为36个月。所有患者均有前胸壁术前和术后的标准化照片。临床检查通过一份原始评估表进行。还要求患者填写一份详尽的满意度表格。通过临床检查和照片分析诊断乳房及胸壁不对称情况。乳房上提 - 隆乳术、乳房重建术、乳房畸形(乳房肥大症和波兰综合征)以及数据不完整的患者被排除在研究之外。使用SPSS 15.0软件进行统计学分析。
结果
胸壁和乳房不对称的比例为77%,乳房不对称的比例为69.5%(乳房体积不对称占26.5%,形状不对称占62.5%)。17%的患者存在孤立的胸壁不对称。脊柱侧弯是不对称的主要原因(占胸壁不对称的52.9%),因为它常伴有胸壁旋转、胸壁凹陷、乳房下凹陷或肋骨不对称。患者术后常注意到不对称情况(28%)。在抱怨术后不对称的患者中,83.3%存在先天性乳房或胸壁不对称。不对称是不满意的第三个原因,也是进行修复手术的第三个理由(排在体积不满意和乳房下垂之后)。要求进行手术修复的患者中有30%以及不满意的患者中有35.3%抱怨不对称,其中83.3%的情况术前就已存在。
结论
将本研究的不对称率与文献中其他研究进行了比较。在日常实践中,可通过全面的临床检查和标准化的胸壁照片诊断不对称情况。应对存在先天性不对称的患者进行教育,以提高术后满意度。作者提出并讨论了一种处理隆乳术中不同类型不对称情况的手术模式。