Mimouni Francis B, Shamir Raanan
Department of Pediatrics, Shaare Zedek Medical Center, Jerusalem, Israel.
Curr Opin Clin Nutr Metab Care. 2009 May;12(3):287-92. doi: 10.1097/MCO.0b013e32832a1329.
To understand the basis for current recommendations for vitamin D supplementation in childhood and the differences between the recommendations published by major expert committees, using the Medline engine of the US National Library of Medicine and the National Institutes of Health.
Recent recommendations published by major national expert committees are essentially based on expert opinion (a relatively low level of evidence). Randomized controlled trials are very few, and there are no systematic reviews or meta-analyses on the topic. Most trials have examined the question of whether a specific daily vitamin D dose is capable or not to prevent rickets (by studying surrogate markers of rickets). There are no trials that have systematically attempted to determine the upper limit of daily vitamin D dose beyond which its toxic effects may appear. Whether or not outcomes such as osteoporosis (or low bone mass) and specific types of cancer may be prevented by 'generous' vitamin D supplementation is unclear and mostly based on indirect epidemiologic data not clearly substantiated by randomized controlled trials
The dose of daily vitamin D supplements needed to prevent rickets is probably much lower than that recommended by most expert committees. Whether higher doses of daily vitamin D supplements may or may not prevent other poor outcomes such as adult osteoporosis or specific types of cancer is not yet known.
利用美国国立医学图书馆和美国国立卫生研究院的Medline数据库,了解当前儿童维生素D补充建议的依据以及主要专家委员会发布的建议之间的差异。
主要国家专家委员会最近发布的建议基本上基于专家意见(证据水平相对较低)。随机对照试验非常少,且尚无关于该主题的系统评价或荟萃分析。大多数试验研究了特定每日维生素D剂量是否能够预防佝偻病(通过研究佝偻病的替代指标)。没有试验系统地试图确定每日维生素D剂量的上限,超过该上限可能会出现毒性作用。“充足”的维生素D补充是否能预防骨质疏松症(或低骨量)和特定类型的癌症等结果尚不清楚,且大多基于随机对照试验未明确证实的间接流行病学数据。
预防佝偻病所需的每日维生素D补充剂量可能远低于大多数专家委员会建议的剂量。每日较高剂量的维生素D补充剂是否能预防其他不良后果,如成人骨质疏松症或特定类型的癌症,目前尚不清楚。