Fraire A E, McLarty J W, Greenberg S D
Department of Pathology, Ben Taub General Hospital, Tyler, TX.
Diagn Cytopathol. 1991;7(4):359-62. doi: 10.1002/dc.2840070407.
We studied the utilization rates of 1) cytopathology procedures [sputum, fine-needle aspirates (FNA), bronchial washings and brushings] versus 2) histopathology procedures (bronchial biopsies, lymph node biopsies, lobectomies, pneumonectomies) in the diagnosis of lung cancer, over two time periods (1967/1987). Comparisons were made in the utilization rates of these two diagnostic procedures in two groups of 100 patients each. Statistically significant changes included 1) an increase of cytopathology procedures, as the sole means of diagnosis; 2) an increase in FNAs; 3) an increased percentage of positive cytopathologic diagnosis; and 4) a decrease of major surgical procedures (lobectomy, pneumonectomy), as means of initial pathologic diagnosis. This study provides data supporting the trend of decreasing surgical procedures for initial diagnosis of lung cancer, with greater, more effective utilization of cytopathologic (particularly FNA) procedures.
我们研究了在两个时间段(1967年/1987年)内,1)细胞病理学检查程序[痰、细针抽吸活检(FNA)、支气管灌洗和刷检]与2)组织病理学检查程序(支气管活检、淋巴结活检、肺叶切除术、全肺切除术)在肺癌诊断中的使用率。对两组各100例患者的这两种诊断程序的使用率进行了比较。具有统计学意义的变化包括:1)作为唯一诊断手段的细胞病理学检查程序增加;2)FNA增加;3)细胞病理学阳性诊断的百分比增加;4)作为初始病理诊断手段的大型外科手术(肺叶切除术、全肺切除术)减少。这项研究提供的数据支持了肺癌初始诊断时手术程序减少的趋势,同时细胞病理学(尤其是FNA)程序得到了更广泛、更有效的应用。