Kinney Dennis K, Teixeira Pamela, Hsu Diane, Napoleon Siena C, Crowley David J, Miller Andrea, Hyman William, Huang Emerald
Genetics Laboratory, McLean Hospital, NB-G-28 115 Mill Street, Belmont, MA 02478, USA.
Schizophr Bull. 2009 May;35(3):582-95. doi: 10.1093/schbul/sbp023. Epub 2009 Apr 8.
Previous surveys found a large (>10-fold) variation in schizophrenia prevalence at different geographic sites and a tendency for prevalence to increase with latitude. We conducted meta-analyses of prevalence studies to investigate whether these findings pointed to underlying etiologic factors in schizophrenia or were the result of methodological artifacts or the confounding of sites' latitude with level of healthcare at those sites. We found that these patterns were still present after controlling for an index of healthcare--infant mortality--and focusing on 49 studies that used similar diagnostic and ascertainment methods. The tendencies for schizophrenia prevalence to increase with both latitude and colder climate were still large and significant and present on several continents. The increase in prevalence with latitude was greater for groups with low fish consumption, darker skin, and higher infant mortality--consistent with a role of prenatal vitamin D deficiency in schizophrenia. Previous research indicates that poor prenatal healthcare and nutrition increase risk for schizophrenia within the same region. These adverse conditions are more prevalent in developing countries concentrated near the equator, but schizophrenia prevalence is lowest at sites near the equator. This suggests that schizophrenia-producing environmental factors associated with higher latitude may be so powerful they overwhelm protective effects of better healthcare in industrialized countries. The observed patterns of correlations of risk factors with prevalence are consistent with an etiologic role for prenatal vitamin D deficiency and exposure to certain infectious diseases. Research to elucidate environmental factors that underlie variations in schizophrenia prevalence deserves high priority.
以往的调查发现,精神分裂症患病率在不同地理位置存在很大差异(超过10倍),且患病率有随纬度升高而增加的趋势。我们对患病率研究进行了荟萃分析,以调查这些发现是指向精神分裂症潜在的病因,还是方法学假象的结果,抑或是各地点的纬度与当地医疗水平相混淆所致。我们发现,在控制了医疗保健指标——婴儿死亡率,并聚焦于49项采用类似诊断和确诊方法的研究后,这些模式仍然存在。精神分裂症患病率随纬度和寒冷气候增加的趋势仍然很大且显著,并且在几大洲都存在。对于鱼类消费量低、皮肤较黑和婴儿死亡率较高的人群,患病率随纬度的增加更大——这与产前维生素D缺乏在精神分裂症中的作用一致。先前的研究表明,在同一地区,产前医疗保健和营养状况不佳会增加患精神分裂症的风险。这些不利条件在赤道附近的发展中国家更为普遍,但精神分裂症患病率在赤道附近的地区最低。这表明,与高纬度相关的导致精神分裂症的环境因素可能非常强大,以至于在工业化国家中压倒了更好的医疗保健的保护作用。观察到的风险因素与患病率的相关模式与产前维生素D缺乏和接触某些传染病的病因学作用一致。阐明精神分裂症患病率差异背后环境因素的研究应高度优先进行。