Testillano M, Fernandez J R, Suarez M J, Gastaca M, Bustamante J, Pijoan J I, Montejo M, Valdivieso A, Ruiz P, Gonzalez J, Ortiz de Urbina J
Gastroenterology and Liver Unit, Hospital de Cruces, Bilbao, Vizcaya, Spain.
Transplant Proc. 2009 Apr;41(3):1041-3. doi: 10.1016/j.transproceed.2009.02.030.
Posttransplant hepatitis C virus (HCV) recurrence has been shown to negatively impact graft and patient survivals. It has been suggested that HCV recurrence among HIV- and HCV-coinfected transplant recipients is even more aggressive.
To compare the histological severity and survival of posttransplant HCV recurrence between HIV- and HCV-coinfected and HCV-monoinfected patients.
Among 72 adult patients who underwent primary liver transplantation at our institution for HCV-related cirrhosis between October 2001 and April 2007. We excluded one coinfected patient who died on postoperative day 5 leaving 12 HIV- and HCV-coinfected patients for comparison with 59 monoinfected patients. When listed, all coinfected patients fulfilled the criteria of the Spanish Consensus Document for transplantation in HIV patients. Immunosuppression did not differ between the two groups: all were treated with tacrolimus + steroids (slow tapering). Aggressive HCV recurrence was defined as cholestatic hepatitis and/or a fibrosis grade > or =2 during the first posttransplant year.
Coinfected patients were younger than monoinfected patients: 45 +/- 6 years vs 55 +/- 9 years (P = .0008). There were no differences in Child score, Model for End-stage Liver Disease score, donor age, graft steatosis, ischemia time, HCV pretransplant viral load or genotype between the groups. Significant rejection episodes were also equally distributed (25% vs 14%; P = .38). Seven coinfected patients and 29 monoinfected patients developed aggressive HCV recurrences (58% vs 49%; P = .75). Median follow-up was 924 days. Global survival at 3 years was 80%. Survivals at 1, 2, and 3 years were 83%, 75%, 62% in the coinfected vs 98%, 89%, 84% in the monoinfected patients, respectively (log-rank test = 0.09).
The severity of histological recurrence was similar among HIV- and HCV-coinfected and monoinfected HCV liver recipients in the first posttransplant year. Mortality attributed to recurrent HCV was similar in the groups. There were no short-term (3-year) differences in survival between the two groups of patients.
移植后丙型肝炎病毒(HCV)复发已被证明会对移植物和患者的存活产生负面影响。有人提出,在同时感染HIV和HCV的移植受者中,HCV复发更为严重。
比较同时感染HIV和HCV的患者与仅感染HCV的患者移植后HCV复发的组织学严重程度和存活率。
在2001年10月至2007年4月期间,我们机构对72例因HCV相关肝硬化接受初次肝移植的成年患者进行了研究。我们排除了1例在术后第5天死亡的合并感染患者,留下12例同时感染HIV和HCV的患者与59例仅感染HCV的患者进行比较。在列入研究时,所有合并感染患者均符合西班牙HIV患者移植共识文件的标准。两组之间的免疫抑制无差异:所有患者均接受他克莫司+类固醇治疗(缓慢减量)。移植后第一年出现胆汁淤积性肝炎和/或纤维化分级≥2级被定义为严重HCV复发。
合并感染患者比仅感染HCV的患者年轻:45±6岁对55±9岁(P = 0.0008)。两组之间在Child评分、终末期肝病模型评分、供体年龄、移植物脂肪变性、缺血时间、移植前HCV病毒载量或基因型方面无差异。严重排斥反应的发生率也相同(25%对14%;P = 0.38)。7例合并感染患者和29例仅感染HCV的患者出现严重HCV复发(58%对49%;P = 0.75)。中位随访时间为924天。3年总体生存率为80%。合并感染患者1年、2年和3年的生存率分别为83%、75%、62%,而仅感染HCV的患者分别为98%、89%、84%(对数秩检验=0.09)。
在移植后的第一年,同时感染HIV和HCV的患者与仅感染HCV的患者肝移植受者中,组织学复发的严重程度相似。两组中因HCV复发导致的死亡率相似。两组患者在短期(3年)内存活率无差异。