"S. Salvatore" Regional Hospital of L'Aquila, L'Aquila (AQ), Italy,
J Orthop Traumatol. 2008 Sep;9(3):123-8. doi: 10.1007/s10195-008-0018-2. Epub 2008 Aug 2.
A locked nail is the principal method used to eliminate rotatory components in femoral and tibial fractures. Nevertheless, weight bearing is not directed onto the fracture site, slowing down the healing process; another possibility is to use a large-diameter nail and ream the canal to obtain as much adherence as possible and increase the grip, but this can cause a number of complications. The expandable nail is a new option that in theory should remove some problems with previous techniques.
This was a retrospective nonrandomized study encompassing 21 femoral fractures and 27 tibial fractures in 45 patients. They were classified according to the AO classification. Clinical and radiological checks were done at one, three, and six months and at one year from the surgery in order to check for signs of clinical and radiological healing. A good alignment was considered to be the presence of a deformity of less than 5 degrees in the sagittal and lateral planes and the absence of rotatory clinically evident problems. This protocol was adhered to up to six months after surgery by all of the patients, while only 62.2% performed the last control. The mean follow-up was 15 months. A second group of 48 consecutive fractures (24 femural and 24 tibial) treated with locked nail was created to compare surgical times.
Appropriate alignment was observed in all cases; the healing process appeared slower: radiological healing occurred in most cases at six months. The following complications were reported: a case of intraoperative fracture widening with no effect on the treatment; a case of a lesion of the tip of the nail with pneumatic system rupture that necessitated nail substitution; two cases of retarded consolidation at six months, with both tibial fractures treated successfully by intralesion platelet gel; a case of incarcerated nail on 17 removals, resolved by shearing. We had no cases of clinically evident compartment syndrome or pulmonary embolism.
The expandable Fixion nail presents significant advantages in the treatment of transverse and short oblique fractures of femur and tibia because it is easy to use, involves minimal X-ray exposure and can control rotations. Nevertheless, it high cost limits its use. We consider it as an alternative to locked nail.
锁定钉是消除股骨和胫骨骨折旋转成分的主要方法。然而,承重不会作用于骨折部位,从而减缓愈合过程;另一种可能性是使用大直径钉并扩髓以获得尽可能多的附着并增加抓地力,但这可能会引起许多并发症。可膨胀钉是一种新的选择,理论上应该可以解决以前技术存在的一些问题。
这是一项回顾性非随机研究,共纳入 45 例患者的 21 例股骨骨折和 27 例胫骨骨折。根据 AO 分类进行分类。在手术后 1、3 和 6 个月以及 1 年进行临床和影像学检查,以检查临床和影像学愈合的迹象。良好的对线被认为是矢状面和侧位的畸形小于 5 度,并且临床上没有明显的旋转问题。所有患者在手术后 6 个月内都遵循了这一方案,而只有 62.2%的患者进行了最后一次控制。平均随访时间为 15 个月。为了比较手术时间,创建了第二组 48 例连续骨折(24 例股骨和 24 例胫骨),采用锁定钉治疗。
所有病例均观察到适当的对线;愈合过程似乎较慢:大多数病例在 6 个月时出现影像学愈合。报告了以下并发症:1 例术中骨折加宽但对治疗无影响;1 例钉尖损伤伴气动系统破裂,需要更换钉;2 例 6 个月时延迟愈合,2 例胫骨骨折均采用血小板凝胶腔内治疗成功;17 例取出时发生嵌顿钉,经剪断解决。我们没有发生明显的筋膜间室综合征或肺栓塞病例。
可膨胀 Fixion 钉在治疗股骨和胫骨横断和短斜骨折方面具有显著优势,因为它易于使用,X 射线暴露量小,并且可以控制旋转。然而,其高成本限制了它的使用。我们认为它是锁定钉的替代方案。