Smith Wade R, Ziran Bruce, Agudelo Juan F, Morgan Steven J, Lahti Zachery, Vanderheiden Todd, Williams Allison
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Denver Health Medical Center, CO 80204, USA.
J Orthop Trauma. 2006 May;20(5):310-4; discussion 315-6. doi: 10.1097/00005131-200605000-00002.
To report the results of using the expandable nailing system in the treatment of femoral and tibial shaft fractures.
Prospective, cohort series.
Two level-1 university trauma centers.
Forty-eight patients with acute, traumatic diaphyseal fractures of the tibia or femur.
Internal fixation of lower extremity long bone fractures using expandable intramedullary nailing.
Perioperative complications and time to healing.
Forty-nine long bone fractures were treated: 22 femoral fractures (OTA classification: 4 type A1, 6 A2, 7 A3, 1 B1, and 4 B2) and 27 tibial fractures (OTA classification: 4 type A1, 11 A2, 9 A3, 0 B1, and 3 B2). There were 13 open fractures and 37 closed fractures. Healing occurred in 37 (75%) fractures without additional interventions. There were 2 tibial delayed unions and 1 femoral and 1 tibial nonunion. Five tibial shaft fractures and 6 femoral fractures shortened by 1.0 cm or more postoperatively. In 3 tibias and 4 femurs, shortening occurred after fractures judged to be length-stable became unstable because of fracture propagation during nail expansion. Five tibias and 3 femurs were converted to standard locked nails because of shortening. The average time to healing, excluding nonunion, was 15 weeks in the tibia and 16 weeks in the femur. The expandable nail resulted in an unplanned reoperation in 12 cases (25%).
We found a high complication rate because of shortening, which was independent of fracture classification. Consequently, we cannot recommend the use of an unlocked, expandable nail in diaphyseal fractures of the femur or tibia.
报告使用可扩张髓内钉系统治疗股骨干和胫骨干骨折的结果。
前瞻性队列研究。
两家一级大学创伤中心。
48例急性创伤性胫骨干或股骨干骨折患者。
使用可扩张髓内钉对下肢长骨骨折进行内固定。
围手术期并发症及愈合时间。
共治疗49例长骨骨折,其中股骨干骨折22例(OTA分型:4例A1型、6例A2型、7例A3型、1例B1型和4例B2型),胫骨干骨折27例(OTA分型:4例A1型、11例A2型、9例A3型)。开放性骨折13例,闭合性骨折37例。37例(75%)骨折无需额外干预即愈合。有2例胫骨干骨折延迟愈合,1例股骨干骨折和1例胫骨干骨折不愈合。5例胫骨干骨折和6例股骨干骨折术后短缩1.0 cm或更多。3例胫骨和4例股骨在判定长度稳定的骨折因髓内钉扩张时骨折移位而变为不稳定后出现短缩。5例胫骨和3例股骨因短缩而更换为标准锁定髓内钉。排除不愈合病例后,胫骨平均愈合时间为15周,股骨为16周。可扩张髓内钉导致12例(25%)患者进行了计划外再次手术。
我们发现因短缩导致的并发症发生率较高,且与骨折分型无关。因此,我们不推荐在股骨干或胫骨干骨折中使用非锁定可扩张髓内钉。