Jiménez-Monreal A M, García-Diz L, Martínez-Tomé M, Mariscal M, Murcia M A
Dept. of Food Science, Veterinary Faculty, Univ. of Murcia, Apdo. Correos 4021, E-30008-Murcia, Spain.
J Food Sci. 2009 Apr;74(3):H97-H103. doi: 10.1111/j.1750-3841.2009.01091.x.
The influence of home cooking methods (boiling, microwaving, pressure-cooking, griddling, frying, and baking) on the antioxidant activity of vegetables has been evaluated in 20 vegetables, using different antioxidant activity assays (lipoperoxyl and hydroxyl radicals scavenging and TEAC). Artichoke was the only vegetable that kept its very high scavenging-lipoperoxyl radical capacity in all the cooking methods. The highest losses of LOO. scavenging capacity were observed in cauliflower after boiling and microwaving, pea after boiling, and zucchini after boiling and frying. Beetroot, green bean, and garlic kept their antioxidant activity after most cooking treatments. Swiss chard and pepper lost OH. scavenging capacity in all the processes. Celery increased its antioxidant capacity in all the cooking methods, except boiling when it lost 14%. Analysis of the ABTS radical scavenging capacity of the different vegetables showed that the highest losses occurred in garlic with all the methods, except microwaving. Among the vegetables that increased their TEAC values were green bean, celery, and carrot after all cooking methods (except green bean after boiling). These 3 types of vegetables showed a low ABTS radical scavenging capacity. According to the method of analysis chosen, griddling, microwave cooking, and baking alternately produce the lowest losses, while pressure-cooking and boiling lead to the greatest losses; frying occupies an intermediate position. In short, water is not the cook's best friend when it comes to preparing vegetables.
已采用不同的抗氧化活性测定方法(脂质过氧自由基和羟基自由基清除能力以及TEAC),对20种蔬菜评估了家庭烹饪方法(煮、微波、高压煮、煎烤、油炸和烘焙)对蔬菜抗氧化活性的影响。洋蓟是唯一在所有烹饪方法中都保持其极高脂质过氧自由基清除能力的蔬菜。在煮和微波处理后的花椰菜、煮后的豌豆以及煮和油炸后的西葫芦中观察到脂质过氧自由基清除能力的最大损失。甜菜根、四季豆和大蒜在大多数烹饪处理后仍保持其抗氧化活性。瑞士甜菜和甜椒在所有处理过程中都失去了羟基自由基清除能力。芹菜在所有烹饪方法中(煮时损失14%除外)其抗氧化能力都有所提高。对不同蔬菜的ABTS自由基清除能力分析表明,除微波处理外,大蒜在所有方法中损失最高。在烹饪方法后其TEAC值增加的蔬菜包括四季豆、芹菜和胡萝卜(煮后的四季豆除外)。这3种蔬菜的ABTS自由基清除能力较低。根据所选分析方法来看,煎烤、微波烹饪和烘焙交替使用造成的损失最低,而高压煮和煮导致的损失最大;油炸处于中间位置。简而言之,在烹饪蔬菜时,水并非厨师的最佳帮手。