Böstman O, Hirvensalo E, Partio E, Törmälä P, Rokkanen P
Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, University Central Hospital, Helsinki, Finland.
J Trauma. 1991 Oct;31(10):1400-3. doi: 10.1097/00005373-199110000-00016.
Within a 6-year period (1984-1989) absorbable pins, rods, and screws made of polyglycolide, polylactide, or lactide-glycolide copolymer were used in the internal fixation of 881 fractures, 73.1% of which were displaced malleolar fractures of the ankle. During the last 3 years the patients treated using absorbable fracture fixation constituted 19.6% of all fracture patients managed by internal fixation at the department. The number of hardware removal procedures avoided during the 6-year period as a result of the use of the absorbable implants was estimated at approximately 700. By determining all direct and indirect costs associated with internal fracture fixation and the influence of the percentage of hardware removal, a cost coefficient was calculated for certain fracture types when treated using absorbable versus metallic internal fixation. In bimalleolar fractures, an optimal indication for absorbable fixation, the coefficient was 1.04 (cost of absorbable fixation 4% higher than that of metallic fixation) if the removal percentage with metallic fixation was zero and 0.91 (cost of absorbable fixation 9% lower than that of metallic fixation) if the removal percentage was 100%. The breakeven point was a removal rate of 31%.
在6年期间(1984 - 1989年),聚乙交酯、聚丙交酯或丙交酯 - 乙交酯共聚物制成的可吸收钢针、钢棒和螺钉被用于881例骨折的内固定,其中73.1%为踝关节移位性踝部骨折。在过去3年中,使用可吸收骨折固定治疗的患者占该科室所有接受内固定治疗骨折患者的19.6%。据估计,在这6年期间,由于使用可吸收植入物而避免的取出内固定器械的手术数量约为700例。通过确定与骨折内固定相关的所有直接和间接成本以及取出内固定器械百分比的影响,计算出了某些骨折类型使用可吸收内固定与金属内固定治疗时的成本系数。在双踝骨折(可吸收固定的最佳适应证)中,如果金属固定的取出百分比为零,成本系数为1.04(可吸收固定成本比金属固定高4%);如果取出百分比为100%,成本系数为0.91(可吸收固定成本比金属固定低9%)。盈亏平衡点是取出率为31%。