Ben Yaghlene H, Leguerinel I, Hamdi M, Mafart P
Université Européenne de Bretagne, IFR ScInBioS, Université de Bretagne Occidentale, Quimper, France.
Int J Food Microbiol. 2009 Jul 31;133(1-2):48-61. doi: 10.1016/j.ijfoodmicro.2009.04.014. Epub 2009 Apr 24.
In this study, predictive microbiology and food engineering were combined in order to develop a new analytical model predicting the bacterial growth under dynamic temperature conditions. The proposed model associates a simplified primary bacterial growth model without lag, the secondary Ratkowsky "square root" model and a simplified two-parameter heat transfer model regarding an infinite slab. The model takes into consideration the product thickness, its thermal properties, the ambient air temperature, the convective heat transfer coefficient and the growth parameters of the micro organism of concern. For the validation of the overall model, five different combinations of ambient air temperature (ranging from 8 degrees C to 12 degrees C), product thickness (ranging from 1 cm to 6 cm) and convective heat transfer coefficient (ranging from 8 W/(m(2) K) to 60 W/(m(2) K)) were tested during a cooling procedure. Moreover, three different ambient air temperature scenarios assuming alternated cooling and heating stages, drawn from real refrigerated food processes, were tested. General agreement between predicted and observed bacterial growth was obtained and less than 5% of the experimental data fell outside the 95% confidence bands estimated by the bootstrap percentile method, at all the tested conditions. Accordingly, the overall model was successfully validated for isothermal and dynamic refrigeration cycles allowing for temperature dynamic changes at the centre and at the surface of the product. The major impact of the convective heat transfer coefficient and the product thickness on bacterial growth during the product cooling was demonstrated. For instance, the time needed for the same level of bacterial growth to be reached at the product's half thickness was estimated to be 5 and 16.5 h at low and high convection level, respectively. Moreover, simulation results demonstrated that the predicted bacterial growth at the air ambient temperature cannot be assumed to be equivalent to the bacterial growth occurring at the product's surface or centre when convection heat transfer is taken into account. Our results indicate that combining food engineering and predictive microbiology models is an interesting approach providing very useful tools for food safety and process optimisation.
在本研究中,将预测微生物学与食品工程相结合,以开发一种新的分析模型,用于预测动态温度条件下的细菌生长。所提出的模型将一个无延迟的简化初级细菌生长模型、二级Ratkowsky“平方根”模型以及一个关于无限平板的简化双参数传热模型关联起来。该模型考虑了产品厚度、其热特性、环境空气温度、对流换热系数以及所关注微生物的生长参数。为了验证整个模型,在冷却过程中测试了环境空气温度(8摄氏度至12摄氏度)、产品厚度(1厘米至6厘米)和对流换热系数(8瓦/(平方米·开尔文)至60瓦/(平方米·开尔文))的五种不同组合。此外,还测试了从实际冷藏食品过程中得出的三种假设交替冷却和加热阶段的不同环境空气温度情景。在所有测试条件下,预测的和观察到的细菌生长之间达成了总体一致,并且不到5%的实验数据落在通过自助百分位数法估计的95%置信带之外。因此,整个模型成功地针对等温及动态制冷循环进行了验证,允许产品中心和表面出现温度动态变化。证明了对流换热系数和产品厚度对产品冷却过程中细菌生长的主要影响。例如,在低对流水平和高对流水平下,产品半厚度达到相同细菌生长水平所需的时间分别估计为5小时和16.5小时。此外,模拟结果表明,当考虑对流换热时,不能假定在空气环境温度下预测的细菌生长等同于在产品表面或中心发生的细菌生长。我们的结果表明,将食品工程和预测微生物学模型相结合是一种有趣的方法,可为食品安全和工艺优化提供非常有用的工具。