Monnier Philippe, Ikonomidis Christos, Jaquet Yves, George Mercy
Department of Otolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, University Hospital (Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Vaudois), Lausanne 1011, Vaudois, Switzerland.
Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol. 2009 Sep;73(9):1217-21. doi: 10.1016/j.ijporl.2009.05.008. Epub 2009 Jun 2.
Creation of a patent subglottic airway after partial cricotracheal resection (PCTR) may not always result in successful decannulation due to associated parameters such as co-morbidity and/or glottic involvement. We classified patients after incorporating these additional parameters into the original Myer-Cotton classification to assess whether this could better predict the outcome measures after PCTR.
One hundred children with Myer-Cotton grade III or IV subglottic stenosis who underwent PCTR between 1978 and 2008 were identified from a prospectively collected database. The patients were classified into four groups based on the association of co-morbidity and/or glottic involvement. Delay in decannulation, revision open surgery and rates of decannulation were the outcome measures compared between the groups.
There were 68 children with Myer-Cotton grade III and 32 children with grade IV stenosis. Based on the new classification, there were 36 children with isolated SGS, 31 with associated co-morbidity, 19 with associated glottic involvement and 14 children with both co-morbidity and glottic involvement. A trend towards less optimal results was noticed with the association of co-morbidity and/or glottic involvement. Statistical significance was reached for maximum decannulation failure in the group with both co-morbidity and glottic involvement. Delayed decannulation significantly correlated in the group with associated glottic involvement.
This new classification is relatively simple and aimed at providing more accurate and uniform prognostic information to both patients and surgeons when dealing with the whole spectrum of severe SGS.
由于合并症和/或声门受累等相关因素,部分环状气管切除术后(PCTR)建立的声门下气道可能无法总是成功拔管。我们将这些额外因素纳入原始的迈耶-科顿分类中对患者进行分类,以评估这是否能更好地预测PCTR后的结局指标。
从一个前瞻性收集的数据库中识别出1978年至2008年间接受PCTR的100例迈耶-科顿III级或IV级声门下狭窄患儿。根据合并症和/或声门受累情况将患者分为四组。比较各组之间的拔管延迟、再次开放手术和拔管率等结局指标。
有68例迈耶-科顿III级患儿和32例IV级狭窄患儿。根据新的分类,有36例单纯声门下狭窄患儿,31例合并合并症患儿,19例合并声门受累患儿,14例既合并合并症又合并声门受累患儿。随着合并症和/或声门受累的出现,观察到结果不太理想的趋势。在既合并合并症又合并声门受累的组中,最大拔管失败率达到统计学意义。在合并声门受累的组中,拔管延迟显著相关。
这种新的分类相对简单,旨在在处理整个严重声门下狭窄范围时,为患者和外科医生提供更准确和统一的预后信息。