Claudio Munari Epilepsy Surgery Center, Sleep Medicine Center, Ospedale Niguarda Ca' Granda, Piazza Ospedale Maggiore, 320162 Milan, Italy.
Epilepsia. 2009 Dec;50(12):2599-604. doi: 10.1111/j.1528-1167.2009.02169.x. Epub 2009 Jun 10.
To analyze the topography of the epileptogenic zone (EZ) and the etiologic substrate as risk factors for sleep-related focal epilepsy.
Three hundred three patients (172 males and 131 females, mean age at surgery 25.6 +/- 13.1 years), who were seizure-free after resective surgery for drug-resistant focal epilepsy, were retrospectively reviewed. Statistical analysis was conducted to evaluate the risk of presenting sleep-related epilepsy (SRE) against topography of resection (assumed to correspond or to include the EZ) and results of histology.
Thirty-nine patients (12.8%) presented with an SRE. At bivariate analysis, a higher frequency of SRE was associated with a frontal lobe EZ (p = 1.94 x 10(-9)) and Taylor's FCD (TFCD, p = 2.20 x 10(-16)), whereas architectural FCD (p = 0.00977), ganglioglioma (p = 0.02508), and mesial temporal sclerosis (p = 2.47 x 10(-5)) were correlated with a reduced frequency of SRE. Multivariate analysis demonstrated that the only variable significantly associated with SRE was the presence of a TFCD, which increased 14-fold the risk of SRE [p = 1.66 x 10(-10); risk ratio (RR) = 14.44].
In this study, we have demonstrated a significant and strong association between SRE and TFCD in a select population of patients with drug-resistant focal epilepsy submitted to surgical resection of the EZ. Although our results cannot be applied to the entire spectrum of SRE, the presence of TFCD as the underlying etiology should be considered when evaluating patients with SRE, because surgery can provide excellent results on seizures in these cases.
分析致痫区(EZ)的解剖结构和病因学基础作为与睡眠相关的局灶性癫痫的风险因素。
回顾性分析了 303 名(男 172 例,女 131 例,手术时平均年龄 25.6±13.1 岁)接受手术治疗的药物难治性局灶性癫痫患者的资料。对这些患者的切除部位(假定与 EZ 相符或包含 EZ)和组织学结果进行统计分析,以评估其发生睡眠相关癫痫(SRE)的风险。
39 例患者(12.8%)出现 SRE。在双变量分析中,SRE 发生频率较高与额叶 EZ(p=1.94×10(-9))和 Taylor 的 FCD(TFCD,p=2.20×10(-16))相关,而结构 FCD(p=0.00977)、神经节细胞瘤(p=0.02508)和海马硬化(p=2.47×10(-5))与 SRE 发生率降低相关。多变量分析表明,与 SRE 显著相关的唯一变量是 TFCD 的存在,其使 SRE 的风险增加 14 倍(p=1.66×10(-10);风险比(RR)=14.44)。
在这项研究中,我们在接受 EZ 切除手术的药物难治性局灶性癫痫患者中发现了 SRE 与 TFCD 之间存在显著且强烈的关联。尽管我们的结果不能应用于 SRE 的全部范围,但在评估 SRE 患者时,应考虑到 TFCD 作为潜在病因的存在,因为在这些情况下手术可以为癫痫发作提供很好的效果。