Calo William A, Quintana Rafael, Catoni Ivan, Valle Yarí, Alvarez Julio J, Colón Wanda M, Delgado Marla S, Estrella Mayra, González Aida L, Kallis María, Marrero Vivienne M, Meléndez Lehida, Miranda Aisha I, Nieves Karen, Osorio Lydiette, Rodríguez José M, Torres Azalia, Suárez Erick, Ortiz Ana P
University of Puerto Rico, Medical Sciences Campus, Graduate School of Public Health, Biostatistics and Epidemiology Department, San Juan, PR 00936-5067.
P R Health Sci J. 2009 Jun;28(2):126-34.
A population-based cross-sectional design was used to compare the prevalence of respiratory and general symptoms and of respiratory and heart diseases in two communities of Juana Díaz, Puerto Rico: Guayabal, exposed to particulate matter from quarries and diesel exhaust; and Río Cañas Abajo, which has no such exposure.
A probabilistic sampling design was used to obtain a representative sample of households and 288 residents of the selected households were interviewed. Adjusted PORs were estimated to assess the relationship between diseases/symptoms and place of residence using logistic regression models. To estimate the parameters of this model, a multilevel approach was used in order to control for potential correlation among residents of the same block.
A higher prevalence of general and respiratory symptoms and of respiratory diseases was observed for residents of Guayabal when compared to Río Cañas Abajo (p < 0.05). Residents of Guayabal were more likely to have bronchitis (adjusted POR = 5.5; p-value < 0.05), nasal allergies (adjusted POR = 4.2; p-value = 0.01), nasal congestion (adjusted POR = 2.9; p-value = 0.02), and nausea and vomiting (adjusted POR = 8.7; p-value < 0.01).
The perception of the community of Guayabal of a higher prevalence of symptoms and health conditions was supported by the present findings. This study provides statistical evidence for the design of an analytical epidemiologic study aimed at evaluating the potential effect of quarrying on adverse health outcomes in the community of Guayabal.
采用基于人群的横断面设计,比较波多黎各胡安娜·迪亚斯两个社区呼吸道和一般症状以及呼吸道和心脏病的患病率:瓜亚瓦尔社区,暴露于采石场颗粒物和柴油废气中;以及下里奥卡尼亚斯社区,未暴露于此类污染物。
采用概率抽样设计获取具有代表性的家庭样本,并对所选家庭的288名居民进行了访谈。使用逻辑回归模型估计调整后的比值比(POR),以评估疾病/症状与居住地点之间的关系。为估计该模型的参数,采用了多级方法以控制同街区居民之间的潜在相关性。
与下里奥卡尼亚斯社区相比,瓜亚瓦尔社区居民的一般和呼吸道症状以及呼吸道疾病患病率更高(p < 0.05)。瓜亚瓦尔社区居民更易患支气管炎(调整后的POR = 5.5;p值 < 0.05)、鼻过敏(调整后的POR = 4.2;p值 = 0.01)、鼻塞(调整后的POR = 2.9;p值 = 0.02)以及恶心和呕吐(调整后的POR = 8.7;p值 < 0.01)。
本研究结果支持了瓜亚瓦尔社区对症状和健康状况患病率较高的认知。本研究为设计一项分析性流行病学研究提供了统计证据,该研究旨在评估采石作业对瓜亚瓦尔社区不良健康结局的潜在影响。