Laqueille X, Launay C, Dervaux A, Kanit M
Service d'addictologie, centre hospitalier Sainte-Anne, université René-Descartes Paris-V, 1, rue Cabanis, 75674 Paris cedex 14 France.
Encephale. 2009 Jun;35(3):220-5. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2008.05.005. Epub 2008 Oct 1.
In spite of its seriousness, dependence on alcohol and benzodiazepines during substitution treatment are poorly documented. Its frequency is nonetheless significant. According to studies, between one and two thirds of patients are affected. This consumption is under verbalized by patients and underestimated by carers. In one study, where the average diazepam doses were from 40 to 45 mg per day, 30% of the patients were taking 70 to 300 mg per day, two thirds having experimented with a fixed dose of 100mg. Benzodiazepines, especially diazepam and flunitrazepam, were studied versus placebo. Thus, 10 to 20mg of diazepam gave rise to euphoria, a sensation of being drugged, sedation and lessening of cognitive performance. The aim of this consumption is to potentiate the euphoria induced by opioids, a "boost" effect during the hour after taking it, or the calming of the outward signs of withdrawal. The most sought after molecules are the most sedative, those with pronounced plasmatic peaks, and the most accessible.
In multidependant subjects, opioid dependence had been earlier in adolescence, with a number of therapeutic failures. They had been faced with repetitive rejection and separation during childhood, medicolegal and social problems. Somatization, depression, anxiety and psychotic disorders are frequent in this subgroup. Heavy drinkers under methadone treatment are highly vulnerable to cocaine. Their behaviour is at risk, with exchange of syringes; their survival rate is 10 years less than that of moderate consumers of alcohol. Most are single, with a previous prison, psychiatric or addictive cursus and they present significant psychological vulnerability. For some authors, benzodiazepines indicate a psychiatric comorbidity. Methadone significantly reduces the consumption of alcohol by nonalcoholic heroin addicts. Although alcohol is an enzymatic inductor of methadone catabolism, with bell-shaped methadone plasma curves over 24 hours, a substitution treatment is recommended. It has a minimum impact on care, in spite of efficiency and retention in therapeutical programs, allowing the subject's inclusion in the framework of a more regular and sustained medical follow-up. Treatment of benzodiazepine dependence by a progressive regression of doses has little efficacy in subjects which cannot control how much medication they are taking. Certain authors have suggested maintenance treatments of clonezepam. The most appropriate therapeutic propositions are: (1) maintenance of therapeutic links though a framework of deliverance from flexible substitution treatment; (2) prevention by cautious prescribing and control of dispensing medication; (3) parallel treatment of psychiatric comorbidities and related personality disorders; (4) individual psychiatric treatment, either institutional or in consistent networks.
尽管酒精和苯二氮䓬类药物依赖在替代治疗期间的严重性,但相关记录却很少。然而,其发生率相当高。根据研究,三分之一到三分之二的患者受到影响。患者对此类药物的使用往往未充分表达,而护理人员也对此估计不足。在一项研究中,地西泮平均剂量为每天40至45毫克,但30%的患者每天服用70至300毫克,三分之二的患者曾尝试过100毫克的固定剂量。对苯二氮䓬类药物,尤其是地西泮和氟硝西泮,与安慰剂进行了对比研究。因此,10至20毫克的地西泮会引发欣快感、药物中毒感、镇静作用以及认知能力下降。这种药物使用的目的是增强阿片类药物所致的欣快感,在服药后一小时内产生“增强”效果,或减轻戒断的外在症状。最受追捧的药物是那些镇静作用最强、血浆峰浓度明显且最容易获取的药物。
在多重药物依赖者中,阿片类药物依赖在青少年时期出现得更早,且有多次治疗失败的情况。他们在童年时期曾面临反复的拒绝和分离、医疗法律及社会问题。在这个亚组中,躯体化、抑郁、焦虑和精神障碍很常见。接受美沙酮治疗的酗酒者极易染上可卡因。他们的行为存在风险,如共用注射器;其生存率比适度饮酒者少十年。大多数人单身,有过入狱、精神病史或成瘾经历,且存在明显的心理脆弱性。对于一些作者来说,苯二氮䓬类药物表明存在精神疾病共病。美沙酮能显著减少非酒精性海洛因成瘾者的酒精摄入量。尽管酒精是美沙酮分解代谢的酶诱导剂,美沙酮血浆曲线在24小时内呈钟形,但仍建议进行替代治疗。尽管它对治疗有一定影响,尽管在治疗方案中有效果且能使患者坚持治疗,但能让患者纳入更规律和持续的医疗随访框架。对无法控制用药量的患者,通过逐渐减少剂量来治疗苯二氮䓬类药物依赖效果不佳。某些作者建议使用氯硝西泮维持治疗。最合适的治疗建议是:(1) 通过灵活替代治疗的解脱框架维持治疗联系;(2) 通过谨慎开药和控制药物配给进行预防;(3) 并行治疗精神疾病共病及相关人格障碍;(4) 进行机构内或连贯网络中的个体精神治疗。