Brodie Jedediah F, Helmy Olga E, Brockelman Warren Y, Maron John L
Division of Biological Sciences, University of Montana, Missoula, Montana 59812, USA.
Ecol Appl. 2009 Jun;19(4):854-63. doi: 10.1890/08-0955.1.
Myriad tropical vertebrates are threatened by overharvest. Whether this harvest has indirect effects on nonhunted organisms that interact with the game species is a critical question. Many tropical birds and mammals disperse seeds. Their overhunting in forests can cause zoochorous trees to suffer from reduced seed dispersal. Yet how these reductions in seed dispersal influence tree abundance and population dynamics remains unclear. Reproductive parameters in long-lived organisms often have very low elasticities; indeed the demographic importance of seed dispersal is an open question. We asked how variation in hunting pressure across four national parks with seasonal forest in northern Thailand influenced the relative abundance of gibbons, muntjac deer, and sambar deer, the sole dispersers of seeds of the canopy tree Choerospondias axillaris. We quantified how variation in disperser numbers affected C. axillaris seed dispersal and seedling abundance across the four parks. We then used these data in a structured population model based on vital rates measured in Khao Yai National Park (where poaching pressure is minimal) to explore how variation in illegal hunting pressure might influence C. axillaris population growth and persistence. Densities of the mammals varied strongly across the parks, from relatively high in Khao Yai to essentially zero in Doi Suthep-Pui. Levels of C. axillaris seed dispersal and seedling abundance positively tracked mammal density. If hunting in Khao Yai were to increase to the levels seen in the other parks, C. axillaris population growth rate would decline, but only slightly. Extinction of C. axillaris is a real possibility, but may take many decades. Recent and ongoing extirpations of vertebrates in many tropical forests could be creating an extinction debt for zoochorous trees whose vulnerability is belied by their current abundance.
众多热带脊椎动物受到过度捕猎的威胁。这种捕猎是否会对与猎物物种相互作用的非捕猎生物产生间接影响,是一个关键问题。许多热带鸟类和哺乳动物会传播种子。它们在森林中的过度捕猎会导致靠动物传播种子的树木种子传播减少。然而,种子传播的这些减少如何影响树木数量和种群动态仍不清楚。长寿生物的繁殖参数通常弹性很低;实际上,种子传播在人口统计学上的重要性仍是一个悬而未决的问题。我们研究了泰国北部四个有季节性森林的国家公园中捕猎压力的变化如何影响长臂猿、赤麂和水鹿的相对丰度,这三种动物是 canopy 树南酸枣种子的唯一传播者。我们量化了传播者数量的变化如何影响四个公园中南酸枣的种子传播和幼苗丰度。然后,我们将这些数据用于一个基于在考艾国家公园(偷猎压力最小)测量的生命率的结构化种群模型,以探讨非法捕猎压力的变化可能如何影响南酸枣的种群增长和持久性。各公园中哺乳动物的密度差异很大,从考艾的相对较高到素贴山 - 普伊山的基本为零。南酸枣的种子传播水平和幼苗丰度与哺乳动物密度呈正相关。如果考艾的捕猎量增加到其他公园的水平,南酸枣的种群增长率将会下降,但幅度很小。南酸枣灭绝是有可能的,但可能需要几十年时间。许多热带森林中脊椎动物近期和持续的灭绝可能正在为靠动物传播种子的树木创造一笔灭绝债务,而这些树木目前的丰富程度掩盖了它们的脆弱性。