Mavrogenis Andreas F, Spyridonos Sarantis G, Antonopoulos Dimitris, Soucacos Panayotis N, Papagelopoulos Panayiotis J
First Department of Orthopaedics, Athens University Medical School, 15562 Holargos thens, Greece.
J Hand Surg Am. 2009 Sep;34(7):1210-5. doi: 10.1016/j.jhsa.2009.04.014. Epub 2009 Jun 25.
To compare the sensory results of patients with low median nerve complete transection and repair, with and without sensory re-education.
We studied 40 patients, aged 20 to 32 years, with low median nerve complete transection. Primary epineural repair using 8-0 single-strand sutures was done in all patients. Hands were immobilized in a splint for 4 weeks, followed by physical therapy for 1 month. At a mean of 3.5 months (range, 3-4 months) after surgery, when vibration sense (pallesthesia), using the 256-cycles-per-second tuning fork, was perceived at the fingertips of the 3.5 radial fingers innervated by the median nerve, the patients were randomly assigned to 2 equal groups: group A patients were rehabilitated with a sensory re-education program, and group B patients had no further treatment. Clinical evaluation at 18 months after surgery (range, 17.5-18.5 months) included locognosia (the ability to localize touch), the static and moving 2-point discrimination tests, and the Moberg pick-up test.
All patients were included in the postoperative evaluation. Static and moving 2-point discrimination were not statistically significant between groups. Locognosia was significantly improved in group A, and a statistical trend was identified regarding the Moberg pick-up test in group A compared to group B.
Sensory re-education appeared to have significant value only in re-education of locognosia at 18 months after low median nerve complete transection and repair.
TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic II.
比较正中神经低位完全横断并修复的患者在接受和未接受感觉再训练情况下的感觉恢复结果。
我们研究了40例年龄在20至32岁之间的正中神经低位完全横断患者。所有患者均采用8-0单股缝线进行一期神经外膜修复。手部用夹板固定4周,随后进行1个月的物理治疗。术后平均3.5个月(范围3至4个月),当用256赫兹音叉在正中神经支配的3.5个桡侧手指指尖感知到振动觉(轻触觉)时,将患者随机分为两组,每组人数相等:A组患者接受感觉再训练计划进行康复治疗,B组患者不再接受进一步治疗。术后18个月(范围17.5至18.5个月)的临床评估包括定位觉(定位触觉的能力)、静态和动态两点辨别试验以及Moberg拾物试验。
所有患者均纳入术后评估。两组之间的静态和动态两点辨别无统计学差异。A组的定位觉有显著改善,与B组相比,A组在Moberg拾物试验方面存在统计学趋势。
感觉再训练似乎仅在正中神经低位完全横断并修复术后18个月的定位觉再训练中具有显著价值。
研究类型/证据水平:治疗性II级。