Yanosky Jeff D, Paciorek Christopher J, Schwartz Joel, Laden Francine, Puett Robin, Suh Helen H
Exposure, Epidemiology and Risk Program, Department of Environmental Health, Harvard School of Public Health, Boston, MA, USA.
Atmos Environ (1994). 2008 Jun 1;42(18):4047-4062. doi: 10.1016/j.atmosenv.2008.01.044.
Chronic epidemiological studies of airborne particulate matter (PM) have typically characterized the chronic PM exposures of their study populations using city- or countywide ambient concentrations, which limit the studies to areas where nearby monitoring data are available and which ignore within-city spatial gradients in ambient PM concentrations. To provide more spatially refined and precise chronic exposure measures, we used a Geographic Information System (GIS)-based spatial smoothing model to predict monthly outdoor PM(10) concentrations in the northeastern and midwestern United States. This model included monthly smooth spatial terms and smooth regression terms of GIS-derived and meteorological predictors. Using cross-validation and other pre-specified selection criteria, terms for distance to road by road class, urban land use, block group and county population density, point- and area-source PM(10) emissions, elevation, wind speed, and precipitation were found to be important determinants of PM(10) concentrations and were included in the final model. Final model performance was strong (cross-validation R(2)=0.62), with little bias (-0.4 mug m(-3)) and high precision (6.4 mug m(-3)). The final model (with monthly spatial terms) performed better than a model with seasonal spatial terms (cross-validation R(2)=0.54). The addition of GIS-derived and meteorological predictors improved predictive performance over spatial smoothing (cross-validation R(2)=0.51) or inverse distance weighted interpolation (cross-validation R(2)=0.29) methods alone and increased the spatial resolution of predictions. The model performed well in both rural and urban areas, across seasons, and across the entire time period. The strong model performance demonstrates its suitability as a means to estimate individual-specific chronic PM(10) exposures for large populations.
对空气中颗粒物(PM)的慢性流行病学研究通常使用城市或县范围内的环境浓度来表征其研究人群的慢性PM暴露情况,这将研究限制在有附近监测数据的区域,并且忽略了城市内部环境PM浓度的空间梯度。为了提供空间上更精细和精确的慢性暴露测量,我们使用基于地理信息系统(GIS)的空间平滑模型来预测美国东北部和中西部地区每月的室外PM10浓度。该模型包括GIS衍生和气象预测因子的月度平滑空间项和平滑回归项。通过交叉验证和其他预先指定的选择标准,发现按道路类别到道路的距离、城市土地利用、街区组和县人口密度、点源和面源PM10排放、海拔、风速和降水等项是PM10浓度的重要决定因素,并被纳入最终模型。最终模型表现强劲(交叉验证R2 = 0.62),偏差很小(-0.4 μg m-3)且精度很高(6.4 μg m-3)。最终模型(带有月度空间项)比带有季节空间项的模型表现更好(交叉验证R2 = 0.54)。与单独的空间平滑(交叉验证R2 = 0.51)或反距离加权插值(交叉验证R2 = 0.29)方法相比,添加GIS衍生和气象预测因子提高了预测性能,并提高了预测的空间分辨率。该模型在农村和城市地区、不同季节以及整个时间段内都表现良好。强大的模型性能表明它适合作为估计大量人群个体特异性慢性PM10暴露的一种方法。