Fox M A, Peterson S, Fabri B M, van Saene H K
Cardiothoracic Centre--Liverpool, UK.
Crit Care Med. 1991 Dec;19(12):1486-90. doi: 10.1097/00003246-199112000-00008.
To test the hypothesis that selective decontamination of the digestive tract improves outcome in cardiac surgical patients.
Prospective, consecutive, controlled trial over two 4-month periods.
Eight-bed, open-plan postcardiac surgery ICU.
All patients undergoing cardiac bypass surgery were eligible. Patients requiring endotracheal intubation for greater than 4 days were included in the analysis. In the initial 4 months, 12 (8.5%) of 141 patients required greater than 4 days of intubation. These 12 patients were not treated with selective decontamination of the digestive tract. We therefore used these patients as the control group. In the second 4-month period, 12 (6.6%) of 180 patients were treated with selective decontamination of the digestive tract and formed the study group.
The primary measure was mortality. Secondary measures included oropharyngeal decontamination and the presence of lower airway infection.
Cephradine prophylaxis. The study group received every 6 hrs 4 mL orally and 20 mL intragastrically a suspension of antimicrobial agents (tobramycin 80 mg, polymyxin E 100 mg, amphotericin B 500 mg), starting on postoperative day 1. The control group did not receive any oral antimicrobial agents.
Mortality rate was significantly (p less than .05) reduced from eight (66%) of 12 patients in the control group to two (16.7%) of 12 patients in the selective decontamination of the digestive tract group. No differences in oropharyngeal decontamination or lower airway infection rates between the two groups were found.
There is a reduced mortality rate in patients receiving selective decontamination of the digestive tract. However, the reader should recognize the small sample size studied. A simple suspension of the antimicrobial agents failed to rid the oropharynx of bacteria.
检验消化道选择性去污可改善心脏手术患者预后这一假设。
在两个4个月期间进行的前瞻性、连续性、对照试验。
有8张床位的开放式心脏手术后重症监护病房。
所有接受心脏搭桥手术的患者均符合条件。分析纳入需要气管插管超过4天的患者。在最初的4个月里,141例患者中有12例(8.5%)需要插管超过4天。这12例患者未接受消化道选择性去污治疗。因此,我们将这些患者用作对照组。在第二个4个月期间,180例患者中有12例(6.6%)接受了消化道选择性去污治疗并形成研究组。
主要指标是死亡率。次要指标包括口咽去污和下呼吸道感染情况。
头孢拉定预防。研究组从术后第1天开始,每6小时口服4毫升、胃内注入20毫升抗菌药物混悬液(妥布霉素80毫克、多粘菌素E 100毫克、两性霉素B 500毫克)。对照组未接受任何口服抗菌药物。
死亡率从对照组12例患者中的8例(66%)显著(p<0.05)降至消化道选择性去污组12例患者中的2例(16.7%)。两组在口咽去污或下呼吸道感染率方面未发现差异。
接受消化道选择性去污的患者死亡率降低。然而,读者应认识到所研究的样本量较小。一种简单的抗菌药物混悬液未能清除口咽部细菌。