Gutierrez Andrew Paul, Gilioli Gianni, Baumgärtner Johann
Division of Ecosystem Science, University of California, Berkeley, CA 194720, USA.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2009 Aug 4;106(31):13136-41. doi: 10.1073/pnas.0813126106. Epub 2009 Jul 20.
International research and development efforts in Africa have brought ecological and social change, but analyzing the consequences of this change and developing policy to manage it for sustainable development has been difficult. This has been largely due to a lack of conceptual and analytical models to access the interacting dynamics of the different components of ecosocial systems. Here, we examine the ecological and social changes resulting from an ongoing suppression of trypanosomiasis disease in cattle in an agropastoral community in southwest Ethiopia to illustrate how such problems may be addressed. The analysis combines physiologically based demographic models of pasture, cattle, and pastoralists and a bioeconomic model that includes the demographic models as dynamic constraints in the economic objective function that maximizes the utility of individual consumption under different level of disease risk in cattle. Field data and model analysis show that suppression of trypanosomiasis leads to increased cattle and human populations and to increased agricultural development. However, in the absence of sound management, these changes will lead to a decline in pasture quality and increase the risk from tick-borne diseases in cattle and malaria in humans that would threaten system sustainability and resilience. The analysis of these conflicting outcomes of trypanosomiasis suppression is used to illustrate the need for and utility of conceptual bioeconomic models to serve as a basis for developing policy for sustainable agropastoral resource management in sub-Saharan Africa.
在非洲开展的国际研发工作带来了生态和社会变革,但分析这种变革的后果并制定政策对其进行管理以实现可持续发展却并非易事。这主要是由于缺乏概念性和分析性模型来研究生态社会系统不同组成部分之间的相互作用动态。在此,我们研究了埃塞俄比亚西南部一个农牧社区持续抑制牛锥虫病所导致的生态和社会变化,以说明此类问题该如何解决。该分析结合了基于生理学的牧场、牛和牧民的种群模型,以及一个生物经济模型,该生物经济模型将种群模型作为动态约束纳入经济目标函数,在牛的不同疾病风险水平下使个体消费效用最大化。实地数据和模型分析表明,抑制锥虫病会导致牛和人口数量增加,以及农业发展加快。然而,在缺乏合理管理的情况下,这些变化将导致牧场质量下降,并增加牛蜱传疾病和人类疟疾的风险,进而威胁系统的可持续性和恢复力。对锥虫病抑制产生的这些相互矛盾的结果进行分析,旨在说明概念性生物经济模型对于制定撒哈拉以南非洲农牧资源可持续管理政策的必要性和实用性。