Department of Pediatrics, Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University, Chicago, IL, USA.
Acad Pediatr. 2009 Sep-Oct;9(5):353-9. doi: 10.1016/j.acap.2009.05.004. Epub 2009 Jul 25.
The goal of this study was to evaluate tobacco-related documentation in children's medical records.
A cross-sectional, consecutive sample of 4216 parents at 13 primary care practices was surveyed on demographics, health habits, and smoking status of household members. The medical records of 2085 children from a subsample of 1149 families (all households with smokers and a sample of nonsmoking households) were reviewed for tobacco-related documentation at the first visit to the practice and visits in the 14 months preceding recruitment. Relationships of documentations with visit type, household smoking status, and use of charting prompts were examined.
Most children (93%) had > or =1 visit during the reviewed period (77% had a health supervision visit), 23% were aged > or =11 years, 52% were Medicaid/uninsured, and 70% lived with smokers; 30.6% of children had family tobacco use status documented at a first visit to the practice and 15.4% had prenatal tobacco use status documented. Among children with a visit in the reviewed period, 39.3% with a health supervision visit and 9.6% without had a tobacco-related notation at a visit (P < .001). Overall, 15.2% of children living with a smoker had a visit notation indicating that someone in the household smoked. In households with smokers, documentation of household tobacco use status often disagreed with parent survey. Charting prompts significantly increased rates of identification of family tobacco use history and prenatal tobacco use history.
Correct identification of household smoking status was absent for most children living with smokers. Improved documentation systems may facilitate tobacco-related surveillance and counseling.
本研究旨在评估儿童病历中与烟草相关的记录。
在 13 个初级保健诊所中,对 4216 名父母进行了横断面、连续样本调查,内容包括人口统计学、健康习惯和家庭成员的吸烟状况。从 1149 个家庭中的子样本(所有有吸烟者的家庭和无吸烟者的样本)中抽取 2085 名儿童的病历,回顾其在首次就诊和招募前 14 个月就诊时与烟草相关的记录。考察记录与就诊类型、家庭吸烟状况和图表提示使用之间的关系。
大多数儿童(93%)在审查期间有≥1 次就诊(77%为健康监督就诊),23%年龄≥11 岁,52%享受医疗补助/无保险,70%与吸烟者同住;30.6%的儿童在首次就诊时记录了家庭烟草使用状况,15.4%记录了产前烟草使用状况。在审查期间有就诊的儿童中,39.3%接受健康监督就诊的儿童和 9.6%未接受健康监督就诊的儿童在就诊时有与烟草相关的记录(P<0.001)。总体而言,15.2%与吸烟者同住的儿童在就诊时有记录表明家中有人吸烟。在吸烟者家庭中,家庭烟草使用状况的记录往往与父母调查不一致。图表提示显著提高了识别家庭烟草使用史和产前烟草使用史的比率。
对于大多数与吸烟者同住的儿童来说,家中吸烟状况的正确识别并不存在。改进的记录系统可能有助于进行与烟草相关的监测和咨询。