Prescrire Int. 2009 Jun;18(101):108-10.
(1) Infliximab and adalimumab, two TNF alpha-inhibitor immunosuppressants, are both available for use as a last resort in Crohn's disease. They are effective in about one in two patients but they carry a risk of serious infections, lymphoma and aggravation of heart failure; (2) Certolizumab is a new TNF alpha-inhibitor monoclonal antibody. It is pegylated to prolong its action, hence the name certolizumab pegol; (3) Certolizumab is sold in the United States for the treatment of Crohn's disease, after failure of conventional treatments. However, the European authorities issued a negative opinion on this drug, and the European Commission refused to grant marketing authorization on 21 May 2008. It is nonetheless available for named-patient compassionate use in France; (4) Certolizumab pegol has not been compared directly with infliximab or adalimumab; (5) In a double-blind placebo-controlled trial including 662 adults with an exacerbation of Crohn's disease, a 6-month course of certolizumab pegol reduced symptom intensity in slightly more patients than placebo (23% versus 16%). However, the rate of clinical remissions was similar (about 12% of patients overall); (6) In a placebo-controlled trial in 428 patients with an initial critical response to certolizumab pegol, maintaining this treatment for 6 months was more effective than switching to placebo. Clinical remissions were obtained at the end of treatment in respectively 48% and 29% of patients; (7) These short-term trials showed a higher frequency of infections with certolizumab pegol than with placebo; these infections ranged from mild respiratory tract infections to fatal tuberculosis. Some patients also developed autoantibodies and anti-certolizumab pegol antibodies, but the clinical implications are unclear. There is also evidence of an excess risk of haemorrhage. The risk of long-term adverse effects remains to be determined; (8) Certolizumab pegol is injected subcutaneously, once a month, on an outpatient basis, while adalimumab is injected twice a month; (9) In practice, as with other TNF alpha inhibitors used in Crohn's disease, certolizumab pegol is only modestly effective and carries a disturbing risk of adverse effects. In the absence of a better alternative, patients with Crohn's disease who might benefit from TNF alpha inhibitor therapy should continue to receive either infliximab or adalimumab, two drugs with which we have more experience.
(1)英夫利昔单抗和阿达木单抗这两种肿瘤坏死因子α抑制剂类免疫抑制剂,在克罗恩病中都可作为最后手段使用。它们对约二分之一的患者有效,但有严重感染、淋巴瘤和心力衰竭加重的风险;(2)赛妥珠单抗是一种新型肿瘤坏死因子α抑制剂单克隆抗体。它经过聚乙二醇化以延长作用时间,因此名为聚乙二醇化赛妥珠单抗;(3)赛妥珠单抗在美国用于治疗常规治疗失败后的克罗恩病。然而,欧洲当局对此药给出了负面意见,欧盟委员会于2008年5月21日拒绝授予其上市许可。不过在法国,它可用于特定患者的同情用药;(4)聚乙二醇化赛妥珠单抗尚未与英夫利昔单抗或阿达木单抗进行直接比较;(5)在一项纳入662例克罗恩病病情加重的成年人的双盲安慰剂对照试验中,6个月疗程的聚乙二醇化赛妥珠单抗使症状减轻的患者略多于安慰剂组(23%对16%)。然而,临床缓解率相似(总体约12%的患者);(6)在一项针对428例对聚乙二醇化赛妥珠单抗初始有显著反应的患者的安慰剂对照试验中,维持该治疗6个月比换用安慰剂更有效。治疗结束时分别有48%和29%的患者实现临床缓解;(7)这些短期试验显示,聚乙二醇化赛妥珠单抗引起感染的频率高于安慰剂;这些感染范围从轻度呼吸道感染到致命性肺结核。一些患者还产生了自身抗体和抗聚乙二醇化赛妥珠单抗抗体,但其临床意义尚不清楚。也有证据表明存在出血风险增加。长期不良反应的风险仍有待确定;(8)聚乙二醇化赛妥珠单抗每月皮下注射一次,在门诊进行,而阿达木单抗每月注射两次;(9)实际上,与用于克罗恩病的其他肿瘤坏死因子α抑制剂一样,聚乙二醇化赛妥珠单抗疗效一般,且有令人不安的不良反应风险。在没有更好替代药物的情况下,可能从肿瘤坏死因子α抑制剂治疗中获益的克罗恩病患者应继续接受英夫利昔单抗或阿达木单抗治疗,我们对这两种药物更有经验。