Ahmed Isra, Banu Haseena, Al-Fageer Reem, Al-Suwaidi Reem
Dubai Medical College, Dubai, UAE.
J Crit Care. 2009 Sep;24(3):e1-7. doi: 10.1016/j.jcrc.2009.06.003.
Medical students represent a highly educated population under significant pressures. They encounter multiple emotions during the transformation from insecure student to young knowledgeable physician. During the transition to clinical settings in the third year, the student may experience a loss of external control and may counter this with an increase in depression and/or anxiety symptoms. Studies suggest that mental health worsens after students begin medical school and remains poor throughout training. It is not just the undergraduate study period, which brings about these changes; it may continue later in internship, postgraduate study, and in physicians' practical life, and it may reach burnout level. The greater the psychosocial health, the greater is the well-being and the capacity for adaptation and overcoming problems and common life frustrations in family, relationships, and work. Medical students and practicing physicians, in comparison with the general population and that of other professions, are exposed to academic and professional stress and therefore are vulnerable to psychosocial health problems and certain specific dysfunctions that may compromise their physical, mental, and social health.
Our study examines the phenomenology of depression and anxiety in medical doctors in 3 government hospitals, 3 primary health care centers and the students (all years) and staff of Dubai Medical College for Girls (DMCG).
This cross-sectional study was conducted in November 2008. One hundred sixty-five medical students of DMCG and 93 doctors (including medical staff of DMCG) completed a set of 2 questionnaires regarding Beck Depression Inventory (BDI) & Beck Anxiety Inventory (BAI). Results were analyzed using SPSS 11, and adequate statistical significant tests were done. A P value of <.05 was considered statistically significant.
Of medical students, 28.6% showed depression and 28.7% showed anxiety. Of medical staff, 7.8% showed depression and 2.2% of them showed anxiety. The second-year medical students exhibited the highest percentage of depression and anxiety. There was a significant correlation between depression and anxiety among medical students (r = 0.6). "Crying" was the most common depressive symptom, and "fear of worst happening" was the most common anxiety manifestation in medical students.
The considerable amount of depression and anxiety found among doctors and students in this study should trigger further work. Studies using more powerful designs would help to illuminate the factors leading to depression and anxiety.
医学生是受过高等教育但面临巨大压力的群体。在从缺乏自信的学生转变为年轻且知识渊博的医生的过程中,他们会经历多种情绪。在三年级过渡到临床实习阶段时,学生可能会感到失去外部控制,进而可能出现抑郁和/或焦虑症状加剧的情况。研究表明,医学生入学后心理健康状况会恶化,且在整个培训期间都持续不佳。引发这些变化的不仅仅是本科学习阶段,在实习、研究生学习以及医生的实际工作生活中可能还会继续,甚至可能达到职业倦怠的程度。心理社会健康状况越好,幸福感就越强,适应能力以及克服家庭、人际关系和工作中常见生活挫折的能力也就越强。与普通人群及其他职业相比,医学生和执业医生面临学术和职业压力,因此易出现心理社会健康问题以及某些可能损害其身心健康和社会健康的特定功能障碍。
我们的研究考察了3家政府医院、3家初级卫生保健中心的医生以及迪拜女子医学院(DMCG)所有年级的学生和教职员工中抑郁和焦虑的表现。
这项横断面研究于2008年11月进行。165名DMCG的医学生和93名医生(包括DMCG的医务人员)完成了一套关于贝克抑郁量表(BDI)和贝克焦虑量表(BAI)的2份问卷。使用SPSS 11对结果进行分析,并进行了充分的统计学显著性检验。P值<.05被认为具有统计学显著性。
医学生中,28.6%表现出抑郁,28.7%表现出焦虑。医务人员中,7.8%表现出抑郁,2.2%表现出焦虑。二年级医学生的抑郁和焦虑比例最高。医学生中抑郁和焦虑之间存在显著相关性(r = 0.6)。“哭泣”是医学生最常见的抑郁症状,“担心最糟糕的事情发生”是最常见的焦虑表现。
本研究在医生和学生中发现的大量抑郁和焦虑情况应促使进一步开展工作。采用更有力设计的研究将有助于阐明导致抑郁和焦虑的因素。