St John of God Psychiatry Rotation, Hospitaller Order of St John of God, Dublin, Ireland.
Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol. 2010 Jun;45(6):631-8. doi: 10.1007/s00127-009-0104-7. Epub 2009 Aug 11.
Involuntary admission legislation and rates differ greatly throughout the European Union Member States. In Ireland, the Mental Health Act 2001 has introduced significant changes in the care for patients admitted involuntarily, including mental health tribunals that review the involuntary admission orders.
To investigate (1) people's perception of the involuntary admission, (2) awareness of legal rights and perception of tribunal, (3) the impact of being admitted involuntarily on the relationship with their family, consultant psychiatrist and prospects for future employment.
Over a 15-month period patients admitted involuntarily to a Dublin Hospital were interviewed using a semi structured interview.
Eighty-one people participated in the study. Seventy-two percent of patients believed that their involuntary admission was necessary at the time and this was associated with greater insight into illness. A total of 77.8% of patients felt that the treatment they received had been beneficial. A total of 86.4% of patients were aware that they had been admitted involuntarily and 45.5% of patients found it easier to accept that they had been admitted involuntarily as their case was reviewed by a tribunal. A total of 27.5% experienced a negative impact upon the relationship with their family as a result of the involuntary admission, while for 15% there was a positive impact. For 26.6% of patients the doctor-patient relationship was negatively impacted upon and a third felt their prospects for employment could be affected.
The majority of patients reflect positively on their involuntary admission and this opportunity should be used to engage patients in follow-up treatment.
在欧盟成员国中,非自愿入院立法和比率存在很大差异。在爱尔兰,2001 年的《精神健康法》对非自愿入院患者的护理引入了重大变革,包括审查非自愿入院令的精神健康法庭。
调查(1)人们对非自愿入院的看法,(2)对法律权利的认识和对法庭的看法,(3)非自愿入院对与家人、顾问精神科医生的关系以及未来就业前景的影响。
在 15 个月的时间里,对一家都柏林医院非自愿入院的患者使用半结构化访谈进行了采访。
共有 81 人参与了这项研究。72%的患者认为他们的非自愿入院在当时是必要的,这与他们对疾病的洞察力增强有关。共有 77.8%的患者认为他们接受的治疗是有益的。共有 86.4%的患者意识到自己被非自愿入院,45.5%的患者发现由于他们的案件由法庭审查,更容易接受自己被非自愿入院。共有 27.5%的患者因非自愿入院而与家人的关系受到负面影响,而 15%的患者则有积极影响。对于 26.6%的患者来说,医患关系受到负面影响,三分之一的患者认为他们的就业前景可能受到影响。
大多数患者对自己的非自愿入院持积极态度,应借此机会让患者参与后续治疗。