Sauvageau Anny, Godin Anny, Desnoyers Sébastien, Kremer Célia
Laboratoire de Sciences Judiciaires et de Médecine Légale, Edifice Wilfrid-Derome, Montreal, QC, Canada.
J Forensic Sci. 2009 Sep;54(5):1089-92. doi: 10.1111/j.1556-4029.2009.01112.x. Epub 2009 Aug 3.
The objective of the present study was to estimate the proportion of hanging victims presenting with limb lesions, to compare this rate between hanging in restraint spaces and in more open settings, and to describe the usual pattern of limb lesions associated with hanging. Two hundred and seven cases of suicidal hanging were retrospectively reviewed and compared to 45 homicidal nonhanging strangulation victims. Bruises incidence was significantly lower in hanging victims (19.8%) compared to homicidal strangulation victims (55.6%). Bruises were more commonly encountered in restraint areas such as closets and staircases (56.3% and 66.7%, respectively) than in more open settings such as barn, bridge, fence, and park. Limb bruises on hanging victims were generally located on the posterior upper limb or the anterior lower limbs, whereas strangulation victims did not display this preferential bruises concentration. Possible suspicion criteria for limb bruises distribution are discussed, in relation to physiopathology of human asphyxia by hanging.
本研究的目的是估计出现肢体损伤的缢吊受害者的比例,比较在受限空间缢吊和在更开阔环境中缢吊的这一比例,并描述与缢吊相关的肢体损伤的常见模式。对207例自杀性缢吊病例进行了回顾性分析,并与45例他杀性非缢吊勒颈受害者进行了比较。缢吊受害者的瘀伤发生率(19.8%)显著低于他杀性勒颈受害者(55.6%)。与谷仓、桥梁、围栏和公园等更开阔的环境相比,壁橱和楼梯等受限区域更常出现瘀伤(分别为56.3%和66.7%)。缢吊受害者的肢体瘀伤通常位于上肢后侧或下肢前侧,而勒颈受害者则没有这种瘀伤集中的偏好。结合缢吊导致人体窒息的生理病理学,讨论了肢体瘀伤分布的可能可疑标准。