Mc Cabe Mark, Fyzul Noorusamah Nadia, Mulligan Linda, Curtis Michael, Cassidy Marie
Department of Histopathology, Cork University Hospital, Wilton, Cork, Ireland.
Department of Clinical and Translational Research, University College Dublin, Belfield, Dublin, Ireland.
J Forensic Leg Med. 2020 Jan;69:101890. doi: 10.1016/j.jflm.2019.101890. Epub 2019 Dec 23.
This retrospective study sought to identify a regular pattern of limb bruising which occurs in association with suicidal or accidental hanging. Following exclusion of cases suspicious for homicide, 82 consecutive cases of hanging from a 10-year period were retrospectively reviewed to identify the pattern of traumatic limb injury in each case. Relevant information such as location, toxicology, and type of suspension was also noted. 72% of the reviewed cases had traumatic limb lesions, the majority of which occurred on the posterior upper limb and the anterior lower limb. Although the distribution of limb injury in our study mirrored that found in the literature, the incidence is much higher than in previous studies (7.4-20%). This could either be due to differences in confounding factors such as intoxication and location of hanging or differences in the practice of recording of limb trauma in hanging between centres. Neither type of suspension nor location of hanging were significantly associated with an increased incidence of traumatic limb injury. Positive toxicology was found to increase the likelihood of sustaining limb injury (p = .044084). In conclusion, the presence of this well documented pattern of traumatic limb lesions in cases of hanging should not always raise suspicion of foul play.
这项回顾性研究旨在确定与自杀或意外缢吊相关的肢体瘀伤规律。在排除可疑的杀人案件后,对10年间连续的82例缢吊病例进行回顾性分析,以确定每例创伤性肢体损伤的模式。还记录了诸如损伤部位、毒理学和悬吊类型等相关信息。72%的回顾病例有创伤性肢体损伤,其中大多数发生在上肢后侧和下肢前侧。尽管我们研究中肢体损伤的分布与文献报道相符,但发生率远高于先前研究(7.4%-20%)。这可能是由于诸如中毒和缢吊地点等混杂因素的差异,或者是各中心在记录缢吊时肢体创伤情况的差异所致。悬吊类型和缢吊地点均与创伤性肢体损伤发生率的增加无显著相关性。发现阳性毒理学结果会增加肢体受伤的可能性(p = 0.044084)。总之,在缢吊病例中出现这种有充分记录的创伤性肢体损伤模式并不总是意味着存在不当行为。