Page Stacey A, Grod Jaroslaw P
Heritage Medical Research Building, Deparment of Community Health Sciences, Faculty of Medicine, University of Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 2009 Jul-Aug;32(6):485-92. doi: 10.1016/j.jmpt.2009.06.010.
This study describes the extent to which chiropractors with Web sites practicing in Canada advertise health products for sale and considers this practice in the context of chiropractic codes of ethics and conduct.
Chiropractic Web sites in Canada were identified using a public online business directory (Canada 411). The Web sites were searched, and an inventory of the health products for sale was taken. The influences of type of practice and province of practice on the sale of health product were assessed. Textual comments about health product marketing were summarized. National and provincial codes of ethics were reviewed, and the content on health product advertising was summarized.
Two hundred eighty-seven Web sites were reviewed. Just more than half of the Web sites contained information on health products for sale (n = 158, 54%). Orthotics were advertised most often (n = 136 practices, 47%), followed by vitamins/nutritional supplements (n = 53, 18%), pillows and supports (n = 40, 14%), and exercise/rehabilitation products (n = 20, 7%). Chiropractors in solo or group chiropractic practices were less likely to advertise health products than those in multidisciplinary practice (P < .001), whereas chiropractors in BC were less likely to advertise nutritional supplements (P < .01). Provincial codes of ethics and conduct varied in their guidelines regarding health product sales.
Variations in codes of ethics and in the proportions of practitioners advertising health products for sales across the country suggest that opinions may be divided on the acceptability of health product sales. Such practices raise questions and considerations for the chiropractic profession.
本研究描述了在加拿大执业且拥有网站的脊椎按摩师销售健康产品的程度,并在脊椎按摩伦理与行为规范的背景下考量这种行为。
利用公共在线商业名录(加拿大411)识别加拿大的脊椎按摩网站。对这些网站进行搜索,并列出待售健康产品清单。评估执业类型和执业省份对健康产品销售的影响。总结有关健康产品营销的文本评论。审查国家和省级伦理规范,并总结健康产品广告的内容。
共审查了287个网站。略超过半数的网站包含待售健康产品信息(n = 158,54%)。最常宣传的是矫形器(n = 136家诊所,47%),其次是维生素/营养补充剂(n = 53,18%)、枕头和支撑物(n = 40,14%)以及运动/康复产品(n = 20,7%)。与多学科执业的脊椎按摩师相比,个体或团体脊椎按摩诊所的脊椎按摩师宣传健康产品的可能性较小(P < .001),而不列颠哥伦比亚省的脊椎按摩师宣传营养补充剂的可能性较小(P < .01)。省级伦理与行为规范在健康产品销售指南方面存在差异。
伦理规范的差异以及全国范围内宣传销售健康产品的从业者比例的不同表明,对于健康产品销售的可接受性可能存在意见分歧。这种行为给脊椎按摩行业带来了问题和思考。