Are Chandrakanth, Stoddard Hugh A, Huggett Kathryn, Franzen John, Mack Andrea, Thompson Jon S
Department of Surgery, University of Nebraska Medical Center, Omaha, Nebraska 68198-4030, USA.
J Surg Educ. 2009 May-Jun;66(3):123-8. doi: 10.1016/j.jsurg.2009.01.001.
Despite the stabilization of match rates, negative perceptions toward general surgery are still rife among medical students. The aim of this study was to describe the attitudes of fourth-year medical students towards general surgery at a regional level.
All fourth-year medical students in the state of Nebraska were invited to complete an online survey about their perceptions of the field of general surgery and the factors that influenced their residency choice.
Of the 145 respondents, 10% were interested in general surgery; this result is slightly higher than the national average. The main reasons cited by those who are choosing general surgery were personal factors; the perceived adverse external factors did not influence their career choice. In contrast, students who chose nonsurgical careers did so because of external factors, such as poor lifestyle and perceptions of an unfriendly environment.
The results of this study suggested regional variations in the level of interest toward general surgery and that interest in the field among medical students in Nebraska may be higher than what has been reported nationally. Students who chose general surgery did so for personal reasons, which were independent of external factors. Recruitment efforts into the field should be focused on those students who choose non-general surgery careers and on rectifying the negative influences that steered them away from the field.
尽管匹配率趋于稳定,但医学生对普通外科的负面看法仍然普遍存在。本研究的目的是描述四年级医学生在地区层面上对普通外科的态度。
邀请内布拉斯加州所有四年级医学生完成一项关于他们对普通外科领域的看法以及影响他们住院医师选择因素的在线调查。
在145名受访者中,10%对普通外科感兴趣;这一结果略高于全国平均水平。选择普通外科的人提到的主要原因是个人因素;所察觉到的不利外部因素并未影响他们的职业选择。相比之下,选择非外科职业的学生是因为外部因素,如不良的生活方式和对不友好环境的看法。
本研究结果表明对普通外科的兴趣水平存在地区差异,并且内布拉斯加州医学生对该领域的兴趣可能高于全国报告的水平。选择普通外科的学生是出于个人原因,这些原因与外部因素无关。该领域的招生工作应侧重于那些选择非普通外科职业的学生,并纠正使他们远离该领域的负面影响。