Brilhault Jean, Ries Michael D
Université François-Rabelais Tours, Tours, France.
Knee. 2010 Mar;17(2):148-51. doi: 10.1016/j.knee.2009.07.008. Epub 2009 Aug 31.
Patellar position during knee flexion was studied in 41 patients with bicruciate substituting (BCS), 41 patients with posterior cruciate retaining (CR) and 41 patients with posterior stabilized (PS) TKA's. The perpendicular height of the patella above the tibial tubercle was compared to the length of the patellar tendon on maximum flexion lateral radiographs. BCS knees had greater active flexion compared to PS and CR knees (BCS=124+/-9.8, PS=112+/-9.5, CR=110+/-10.9). In flexion, apparent patella infera (API) or the height of the patella above the tibial tubercle was 3.5% lower than the patellar tendon length for BCS knees, 1.7% lower in PS knees and 0.5% lower in CR knees. API in PS and BCS knees correlated with active knee flexion, but not in CR knees. Our findings indicate that an apparent inferior position of the patella occurs in BCS knees during deep flexion which is not caused by significant patellar ligament shortening or joint line elevation, but associated with normal posterior rollback of the femur.
对41例采用双交叉替代(BCS)、41例采用后交叉保留(CR)和41例采用后稳定型(PS)全膝关节置换术(TKA)的患者在膝关节屈曲时的髌骨位置进行了研究。在最大屈曲位的侧位X线片上,将髌骨在胫骨结节上方的垂直高度与髌腱长度进行比较。与PS和CR膝关节相比,BCS膝关节的主动屈曲度更大(BCS=124±9.8,PS=112±9.5,CR=110±10.9)。在屈曲时,BCS膝关节的明显髌骨低位(API)或髌骨在胫骨结节上方的高度比髌腱长度低3.5%,PS膝关节低1.7%,CR膝关节低0.5%。PS和BCS膝关节的API与膝关节主动屈曲相关,但CR膝关节不相关。我们的研究结果表明,在深度屈曲时,BCS膝关节会出现明显的髌骨低位,这不是由髌韧带明显缩短或关节线抬高引起的,而是与股骨正常的后滚有关。