Jones B J, Twomey P J
Department of Clinical Biochemistry, The Ipswich Hospital, Ipswich, UK.
J Clin Pathol. 2009 Sep;62(9):816-9. doi: 10.1136/jcp.2008.060798.
To compare the impact and effectiveness of introducing reflective and reflex testing of magnesium in severe hypokalaemia.
All specimens with [K] < or =2.5 mmol/l were retrospectively identified in three 6-month periods: baseline, with reflective testing, and with reflex testing. For each episode of hypokalaemia it was noted whether [Mg] was measured.
Measurement of [Mg] increased from 7.7% to 63.9% (p<0.001) after introducing reflective testing, and then to 98.7% (p<0.001) with reflex testing. Diagnosis of hypomagnesaemia increased from 7.7% to 43.1% (p<0.001) and 69.3% (p<0.01) with reflective and reflex testing, respectively. For severe hypomagnesaemia ([Mg] <0.50 mmol/l) the increase was from 1.9% to 8.3% (p = 0.127 relative to baseline) with reflective testing and then to 12.0% with reflex testing (p<0.05 relative to baseline and p = 0.463 relative to reflective testing). The number of tests needed to diagnose was similar for reflective and reflex testing: 1.48 and 1.42 for hypomagnesaemia, respectively; and 7.67 and 8.22 for severe hypomagnesaemia, respectively. 42 and 70 extra magnesium assays compared to baseline were requested due to reflective and reflex testing, respectively.
Reflex testing was the most time-efficient and consistent method of diagnosing hypomagnesaemia in severe hypokalaemia. This was mainly due to the increased number of magnesium assays performed. However, as the absolute increase in test numbers was small (28 in a 6-month period) and the test is inexpensive, selective reflex testing can improve quality in a cost-efficient manner.
比较在严重低钾血症中引入镁的反射性和反应性检测的影响及效果。
在三个6个月期间对所有血钾浓度[K]≤2.5 mmol/L的标本进行回顾性分析:基线期、反射性检测期和反应性检测期。记录每例低钾血症发作时是否检测了血镁浓度[Mg]。
引入反射性检测后,血镁浓度检测率从7.7%升至63.9%(p<0.001),随后采用反应性检测时升至98.7%(p<0.001)。反射性检测和反应性检测时,低镁血症的诊断率分别从7.7%升至43.1%(p<0.001)和69.3%(p<0.01)。对于严重低镁血症([Mg]<0.50 mmol/L),反射性检测时从1.9%升至8.3%(相对于基线期p = 0.127),随后反应性检测时升至12.0%(相对于基线期p<0.05,相对于反射性检测p = 0.463)。反射性检测和反应性检测诊断所需的检测次数相似:低镁血症分别为1.48次和1.42次;严重低镁血症分别为7.67次和8.22次。由于反射性检测和反应性检测,分别比基线期多申请了42次和70次血镁检测。
反应性检测是诊断严重低钾血症患者低镁血症最省时且一致的方法。这主要归因于血镁检测次数的增加。然而,由于检测次数的绝对增加量较小(6个月期间增加28次)且检测成本低廉,选择性反应性检测能够以具有成本效益的方式提高医疗质量。