Werner Gerald S, Moehlis Hiller, Tischer Karlheinz
Medizinische Klinik (Cardiology & Intensive Care), Klinikum Darmstadt, Darmstadt, Germany.
EuroIntervention. 2009 May;5 Suppl D:D79-83.
Among lesions with in-stent restenosis (ISR), the in-stent chronic re-occlusions (ISR-CTO) is a subset with particularly unfavourable features regarding both the repeat procedure success and the prevention of lesion recurrence. A review of the literature and personal databases reveals that the prevalence of complete occlusive ISR represents about 5-10% of all CTO lesions, with little evidence regarding the successful long-term treatment. In fact, these lesions had been excluded from large contemporary trials dealing with the best modality for ISR management, and which showed eventually the superiority of drug-eluting stents (DES) as compared to brachytherapy. Only a limited experience exists with brachytherapy for ISR-CTOs, showing an inferior outcome as compared to non-occlusive ISRs. The lack of large study experience is true also for DES, so that only anecdotal experience in small series of patients is available. In some of the recent studies of DES in CTOs, again, ISR-CTOs were not included. Our own experience shows a slightly lower primary success rate of about 70% in ISR-CTOs as compared to 85% in primary CTOs, with a slightly higher recurrence rate with DES of 25%. ISR-CTOs are a clinical problem that had not been systematically addressed. However, we hope that this lesion subset may be of less relevance in the future when the use of DES in lesions which are prone for lesion recurrence will lead to less diffuse and occlusive ISR, and leaves rather focal and better manageable recurrent lesions.
在支架内再狭窄(ISR)病变中,支架内慢性再闭塞(ISR-CTO)是一个亚组,在重复手术成功率和病变复发预防方面具有特别不利的特征。对文献和个人数据库的回顾显示,完全闭塞性ISR的患病率约占所有CTO病变的5%-10%,关于成功的长期治疗的证据很少。事实上,这些病变已被排除在处理ISR管理最佳方式的大型当代试验之外,这些试验最终显示药物洗脱支架(DES)比近距离放射治疗更具优势。对于ISR-CTO的近距离放射治疗只有有限的经验,与非闭塞性ISR相比结果较差。对于DES来说,同样缺乏大型研究经验,因此只有少量患者系列的轶事性经验。在最近一些关于CTO中DES的研究中,ISR-CTO再次未被纳入。我们自己的经验表明,与原发性CTO的85%相比,ISR-CTO的初次成功率略低,约为70%,DES的复发率略高,为25%。ISR-CTO是一个尚未得到系统解决的临床问题。然而,我们希望当在易发生病变复发的病变中使用DES导致较少的弥漫性和闭塞性ISR,并留下更局灶性且更易于管理的复发性病变时,这个病变亚组在未来可能不太重要。