Zeidan Smart, Gorincour Guillaume, Potier Alain, Ughetto Fabrice, Dubus Jean C, Chrestian Marie-Anne, Grosse Camille, Gamerre Marc, Guys Jean-Michel, de Lagausie Pascal
Department of Pediatric Surgery, Timone-enfants Hospital, Marseille, France.
Respirology. 2009 Sep;14(7):1005-11. doi: 10.1111/j.1440-1843.2009.01591.x.
This study evaluated the accuracy of prenatal MRI and postnatal CT imaging in the identification of congenital cystic adenomatoid malformation and bronchopulmonary sequestration by comparison with histological analysis.
Over a 3-year period, 15 patients with lung malformations diagnosed prenatally by ultrasound were referred for prenatal MRI, and all were investigated postnatally by chest CT. All asymptomatic newborns with unresolved lesions underwent elective surgery by thoracoscopy. All surgical specimens were analysed histologically.
Among the 15 patients with an abnormality diagnosed by ultrasound, prenatal MRI findings differed from the final histological diagnosis with respect to extent (n = 3), type of lesion (n = 1) and aberrant vessel identification (n = 4). Postnatal chest CT failed to visualize the aberrant vessel in one patient. Complete regression of the lesion was noted in two patients with bronchopulmonary sequestration, and in one patient with congenital cystic adenomatoid malformation and was confirmed by CT. Elective thoracoscopic lobectomy of the affected lobe was performed for 12 patients. Two conversions to thoracotomy were required. All operated patients had an uneventful hospital course.
Prenatal MRI is less accurate than postnatal CT scan, which remains the most reliable diagnostic modality to specify the location and extent and kind of lesions.
本研究通过与组织学分析相比较,评估产前MRI和产后CT成像在识别先天性囊性腺瘤样畸形和肺隔离症方面的准确性。
在3年期间,15例经超声产前诊断为肺畸形的患者被转诊进行产前MRI检查,所有患者产后均接受胸部CT检查。所有无症状且病变未消退的新生儿均通过胸腔镜进行择期手术。所有手术标本均进行组织学分析。
在15例经超声诊断异常的患者中,产前MRI检查结果在范围(n = 3)、病变类型(n = 1)和异常血管识别(n = 4)方面与最终组织学诊断不同。产后胸部CT未能显示1例患者的异常血管。2例肺隔离症患者和1例先天性囊性腺瘤样畸形患者的病变完全消退,并经CT证实。12例患者接受了患侧肺叶的择期胸腔镜肺叶切除术。需要2例转为开胸手术。所有接受手术的患者住院过程均顺利。
产前MRI的准确性低于产后CT扫描,后者仍然是确定病变位置、范围和类型最可靠的诊断方法。