Tapp Dylan, Thomson George
Department of Public Health, Te Tari Hauora Tumatanui, University of Otago, Box 7343 Wellington South, New Zealand.
N Z Med J. 2009 Sep 25;122(1303):54-66.
To conduct a rapid appraisal of the attitudes of New Zealand decision makers and tobacco control stakeholders on enacting a smokefree cars law.
A media and document search was made for relevant official and other statements. In early 2008, nine semi-structured interviews were carried out involving three MPs, two officials of government health agencies and four members of NGOs with a stake in tobacco control. Interviews were audiotaped, transcribed, and analysed for themes.
In official statements, and amongst the interview sample, there was general opposition to giving smokefree car legislation a current high priority. Reasons given for opposition to such a law included the suboptimal use of advocacy capital compared with other initiatives (e.g. tobacco display bans), the perceived success of relevant health marketing campaigns, and concerns over the current political will to enact legislation that targets smoker freedoms.
More information on the extent of current child exposure to tobacco smoke in New Zealand cars, and on the reach and effectiveness of the New Zealand smokefree cars media campaign would help advocates and policymakers. Wider dissemination to policymakers of New Zealand public and smoker support for banning smoking in cars, and of the progress overseas on smokefree car laws, appears to be essential.
对新西兰决策者和烟草控制利益相关者在制定无烟汽车法律方面的态度进行快速评估。
对相关官方声明和其他声明进行媒体及文件搜索。2008年初,进行了9次半结构化访谈,涉及3名议员、2名政府卫生机构官员以及4名在烟草控制方面有利害关系的非政府组织成员。访谈进行了录音、转录并分析主题。
在官方声明以及访谈样本中,普遍反对将无烟汽车立法列为当前高度优先事项。反对该法律的理由包括,与其他举措(如烟草展示禁令)相比,倡导资源利用不够理想、相关健康营销活动被认为取得成功,以及对当前制定针对吸烟者自由的立法的政治意愿存在担忧。
获取更多关于新西兰儿童当前在汽车中接触烟草烟雾程度的信息,以及关于新西兰无烟汽车媒体宣传活动的覆盖范围和效果的信息,将有助于倡导者和政策制定者。向政策制定者更广泛地传播新西兰公众和吸烟者对禁止在车内吸烟的支持,以及海外无烟汽车法律的进展情况,似乎至关重要。