Department of Orthodontics, Baylor College of Dentistry, Dallas, TX 75246, USA.
Angle Orthod. 2010 Mar;80(2):247-53. doi: 10.2319/042109-226.1.
To evaluate differences in long-term postretention changes between adolescents and adults.
The sample included 96 subjects, 51 adolescents and 45 adults (14.2 +/- 0.8 and 21.5 +/- 6.8 years of age, respectively, at the end of treatment) retained for 3 years and followed approximately 16 years post treatment, who were randomly selected from two private practices. Prior to treatment, 38 and 58 had Class I and Class II malocclusions, respectively.
With the exception of adult midlines, all of the occlusal variables (overjet [0.50-0.77 mm], overbite [0.85-0.95 mm], the maxillary incisor irregularity [0.69-0.80 mm], the mandibular incisor irregularity [0.85-1.50 mm] and the PAR score [0.86-1.92 points]) showed significant increases over time. Adolescents consistently showed greater increases of the occlusal variables than adults, with mandibular incisor irregularity and the PAR index attaining statistically significant (P < .05) levels. Arch length and mandibular intercanine width showed statistically significant decreases over time in both groups; maxillary intercanine and intermolar widths did not change significantly. Overjet increased significantly more in Class II patients than in Class I patients, whereas Class I patients showed significantly greater decreases in mandibular intermolar width than Class II patients.
Over the 16-year posttreatment period, adolescents showed significantly greater increases in mandibular incisor irregularity, and the PAR index than adults. Treated Class I patients demonstrated less increase in overjet and greater decreases in mandibular intermolar width than Class II patients.
评估青少年和成人在保持器佩戴后长期的改变差异。
该样本包括 96 名受试者,51 名青少年和 45 名成人(分别在治疗结束时为 14.2 +/- 0.8 岁和 21.5 +/- 6.8 岁),并随访约 16 年。这些患者均随机选自两家私人诊所。在治疗前,38 名患者有安氏 I 类错颌,58 名患者有安氏 II 类错颌。
除了成人的中线外,所有的咬合变量(覆牙合 [0.50-0.77 毫米]、覆盖 [0.85-0.95 毫米]、上颌切牙不整齐 [0.69-0.80 毫米]、下颌切牙不整齐 [0.85-1.50 毫米]和 PAR 评分 [0.86-1.92 分])都随着时间的推移呈现出显著的增加。青少年的咬合变量增加幅度始终大于成人,下颌切牙不整齐和 PAR 指数达到了统计学显著水平(P <.05)。两组的牙弓长度和下颌尖牙间宽度均随时间呈现出统计学显著的减少;上颌尖牙间宽度和磨牙间宽度没有显著变化。安氏 II 类错颌患者的覆牙合增加明显多于安氏 I 类错颌患者,而安氏 I 类错颌患者的下颌磨牙间宽度减少明显多于安氏 II 类错颌患者。
在治疗后 16 年的随访期间,青少年的下颌切牙不整齐和 PAR 指数的增加幅度明显大于成人。与安氏 II 类错颌患者相比,治疗后的安氏 I 类错颌患者的覆牙合增加幅度较小,下颌磨牙间宽度减少幅度较大。