University of Groningen and University Medical Center Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands.
Med Teach. 2009 Nov;31(11):e494-9. doi: 10.3109/01421590902744894.
Previous research revealed relationships between learning strategies and knowledge acquisition. During clerkships, however, students' focus widens beyond mere knowledge acquisition as they further develop overall competence. This shift in focus can influence learning strategy use.
We explored which learning strategies were used during clerkships and their relationship to clinical performance.
Participants were 113 (78%) clerks at the university hospital or one of six affiliated hospitals. Learning strategies were assessed using the 'Approaches to Learning at Work Questionnaire' (deep, surface-rational and surface-disorganised learning). Clinical performance was calculated by taking the mean of clinical assessment marks. The relationship between learning strategies and clinical performance was explored using regression analysis.
Most students (89%) did not clearly prefer a single learning strategy. No relationship was found between learning strategies and clinical performance.
Since overall competence comprises integration of knowledge, skills and professional behaviour, we assume that students without a clear preference use more than one learning strategy. Finding no relationship between learning strategies and clinical performance reflects the complexity of clinical learning. Depending on circumstances it may be important to obtain relevant information quickly (surface-rational) or understand material thoroughly (deep). In future research we will examine when and why students use different learning strategies.
先前的研究揭示了学习策略与知识获取之间的关系。然而,在实习期间,学生的关注点不仅限于知识获取,而是进一步发展整体能力。这种关注点的转变会影响学习策略的使用。
我们探讨了实习期间使用的学习策略及其与临床表现的关系。
参与者为大学医院或六家附属医院的 113 名(78%)实习医生。使用“工作学习方法问卷”(深度学习、表面理性学习和表面无序学习)评估学习策略。临床表现通过临床评估分数的平均值计算。使用回归分析探讨学习策略与临床表现之间的关系。
大多数学生(89%)没有明显偏好单一的学习策略。学习策略与临床表现之间没有关系。
由于整体能力包括知识、技能和专业行为的整合,我们假设没有明确偏好的学生使用多种学习策略。学习策略与临床表现之间没有关系反映了临床学习的复杂性。根据情况,快速获取相关信息(表面理性)或彻底理解材料(深度学习)可能很重要。在未来的研究中,我们将研究学生何时以及为何使用不同的学习策略。