Streit K J, Stevens N H, Stevens V J, Rossner J
Kaiser Permanente Center for Health Research, Portland, OR 97215.
J Am Diet Assoc. 1991 Feb;91(2):213-6.
Overriding concerns about the accuracy of self-reported food records have overshadowed discussion of their practical value as a self-management, intervention tool. This study examined the relationship between keeping food records and subsequent weight loss in a large-scale, conservative weight loss program. Keeping food records was a better predictor of weight loss than were baseline body mass index, exercise, and age. Monthly as well as cumulative weight loss was directly related to the number of days in which food records were kept. The strong, linear relationship between food record patterns and weight loss suggests that in spite of legitimate concern about the accuracy and representativeness of self-reported food records, they have considerable power as a predictor of success in achieving weight loss.
对自我报告的饮食记录准确性的过度担忧,掩盖了对其作为自我管理干预工具的实用价值的讨论。本研究在一个大规模的保守减肥项目中,考察了记录饮食与随后体重减轻之间的关系。与基线体重指数、运动和年龄相比,记录饮食能更好地预测体重减轻情况。每月以及累计的体重减轻与记录饮食的天数直接相关。饮食记录模式与体重减轻之间强烈的线性关系表明,尽管对自我报告的饮食记录的准确性和代表性存在合理担忧,但它们在预测减肥成功方面具有相当大的作用。