Saravay S M, Steinberg M D, Weinschel B, Pollack S, Alovis N
Long Island Jewish Medical Center, New Hyde Park, NY 11042.
Am J Psychiatry. 1991 Mar;148(3):324-9. doi: 10.1176/ajp.148.3.324.
As general hospitals search for ways to cut costs without sacrificing efficiency, particular attention has been focused on factors that may prolong hospital stay. The results of prior studies that have reported an association between psychological and psychiatric comorbidity and longer hospital stays have been subject to different interpretations because of methodological design flaws. The current paper reports on a study of psychological comorbidity and length of stay that has been designed to avoid the methodological problems of earlier investigations.
The study was performed at a 429-bed tertiary-care, university-affiliated, voluntary, teaching hospital. During hospital days 3 to 5, patients were tested as available with the Mini-Mental State examination, the Zung Depression Inventory, and the SCL-90 and were rated for physical impairment with the Karnofsky Performance Status Scale. Statistical analyses were performed for correlations between length of stay and test scores, rating scales, and demographic and discharge data from the chart.
Of 424 patients approached, 321 (76%) agreed to participate and 278 (65.6%) completed the test battery. Depression, anxiety, and organicity, measured by psychological tests, were significantly correlated with longer hospital stay. These correlations remained significant after the authors controlled for degree of physical impairment, emergency versus elective admission, and medical versus surgical service, which were themselves correlated with longer hospital stay.
This study confirms a significant correlation between psychological comorbidity and length of stay after correcting for the methodological pitfalls found in earlier studies. The clinical, research, economic, and policy implications of these findings are discussed.
随着综合医院寻求在不牺牲效率的情况下削减成本的方法,人们特别关注可能延长住院时间的因素。先前的研究报告了心理和精神共病与更长住院时间之间的关联,但其结果因方法设计缺陷而受到不同的解读。本文报告了一项关于心理共病与住院时间的研究,该研究旨在避免早期调查中的方法问题。
该研究在一家拥有429张床位的三级医疗、大学附属、志愿性教学医院进行。在住院的第3至5天,对有空余时间的患者进行简易精神状态检查、zung抑郁自评量表和症状自评量表90项的测试,并用卡氏功能状态量表对身体损伤进行评分。对住院时间与测试分数、评分量表以及病历中的人口统计学和出院数据之间的相关性进行了统计分析。
在424名被邀请的患者中,321名(76%)同意参与,278名(65.6%)完成了全部测试。通过心理测试测得的抑郁、焦虑和器质性病变与更长的住院时间显著相关。在作者控制了身体损伤程度、急诊与择期入院以及内科与外科服务等因素后,这些相关性仍然显著,而这些因素本身与更长的住院时间相关。
本研究证实了在纠正早期研究中发现的方法缺陷后,心理共病与住院时间之间存在显著相关性。讨论了这些发现的临床、研究、经济和政策意义。